29/10/2026
Roll no 12's assimilated single patient data linked below
Here is the 6-point CBME evaluation for *2023 Batch - Roll No. 12* - Portfolio: *CASE 2 - 26M, Businessman, Urine Output Decreased - 2 Days, Breathlessness - 3 Days, Swelling Both Feet - 3 Days,
CKD - 3 Years, Haemodialysis - 1.5 Years, 2 Times / Week, AV Fistula, Urine 200 ml / Day, BP 160/90, Pallor +, Edema +*
Based on the anonymized text you pasted. Score 0-2 per level. Total /12.
### 1. Remember - Knowledge Recall
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Demographics - Age / Sex: 26 years / Male, Occupation: Businessman, chief complaints - Urine output decreased since 2 days, Breathlessness since 3 days, Swelling (mild) on both feet since 3 days, HOPI - Asymptomatic 3 years ago, then diagnosed with HTN, CKD and HTN, 3 years ago developed mild bilateral pedal edema, initially ankles progressing to leg, Swelling insidious, gradually progressive, bilateral edema (non-pitting), relieved by rest, 3 years ago noticed oliguria, progressive, No hematuria, Since 3 years ago diagnosed with CKD on blood test, Since then taking hemodialysis - since 1.5 years, 2 times/week, through AV fistula, HOPI Continued - No fever, productive cough, chest pain, Past History - Known case HTN 3 years, CKD 3 years - Haemodialysis, No TB, Asthma, COPD, Personal History - Appetite Decreased, Diet Mixed, Sleep Disturbed, Bowel Regular, Bladder Oliguria 200 ml/day, Addiction No, Family History - No significant, General Examination - Alert, well oriented to TPP, PICCLE: P - Pallor Present (+), I - Icterus Absent, C - Cyanosis Absent, C - Clubbing Absent, L - Lymphadenopathy Absent, E - Edema Present (+) - Pedal edema, pitting edema, Vitals - BP 160/90 mmHg, RR 20/min, Temp 98°F, SpO2 94% on Room Air, Systemic Examination - CVS S1 S2 present (+), CNS NFND, RS NVBS BAE (+), P/A Soft, Non-Tender, AV Fistula Examination - Cephalic & Radial Vein, Inspection: Surgical scar, No prominent vein, No redness, Palpation: Palpable continuous thrill, Mild swelling present.
- Good details: Timeline - asymptomatic 3 years ago, CKD + HTN 3 years, dialysis 1.5 years, acute - urine ↓ 2 days, breathlessness 3 days, swelling 3 days - acute on chronic, edema pattern - ankles -> leg, insidious, progressive, bilateral, relieved rest, oliguria - 200 ml/day, dialysis - 2 times/week, AV fistula - Cephalic & Radial, Inspection + Palpation - scar, no redness, thrill +, mild swelling, PICCLE - Pallor +, Edema + - pitting - complete, vitals - BP, RR, Temp, SpO2 - complete except Pulse.
- Gaps: *Contradiction - HOPI "edema (non-pitting)" vs PICCLE "Edema Present (+) - Pedal edema, pitting edema"* - which one? *Pulse - Not recorded.* *No AV Fistula Auscultation - Bruit - missing.* *No Investigations - RFT, CBC, Hb, Electrolytes, eGFR.* *No Last dialysis date, No Dry weight, No Interdialytic weight gain.* *No Drug History - which antihypertensive?* *No Cause of CKD - HTN? Glomerulonephritis?*
*Score: 2 / 2*
- Full recall - timeline, acute on chronic, dialysis, urine output, PICCLE, vitals, fistula exam - all present.
- *Next target:* Fix contradiction - pitting vs non-pitting - CKD edema is pitting, so HOPI should be pitting. Always record Pulse - in CKD + breathlessness + HTN, Pulse is essential. Always add AV Fistula Auscultation - Bruit + / -. Always record Investigations - RFT - urea, creatinine, eGFR, CBC - Hb - Pallor + needs Hb, Electrolytes - K, Ca, Phosphate, Chest X-ray. Always record Last dialysis, Dry weight, Drug History - Telmisartan / Amlodipine?
### 2. Understand - Comprehension
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Acute on chronic pattern - urine ↓ 2 days, breathlessness 3 days, swelling 3 days on CKD 3 years + dialysis 1.5 years - described.
- But no explanation in own words of why CKD causes urine ↓, breathlessness, swelling, pallor.
- No explanation of AV fistula - why thrill = working, why mild swelling - not explained. No explanation of BP 160/90, SpO2 94%, Pallor + - not explained.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial comprehension.
- *Next target:* Explain: CKD -> kidneys cannot make urine -> oliguria 200 ml/day, urine ↓ 2 days = worsening. Explain: Fluid overload -> swelling feet, breathlessness 3 days - fluid in lungs. Explain: Pallor + = anaemia - kidney does not make erythropoietin + blood loss on dialysis, Hb low. Explain: BP 160/90 = uncontrolled HTN due to fluid overload + kidney failure. Explain: SpO2 94% = low, RR 20 = tachypnoea, due to fluid in lungs + anaemia. Explain: AV Fistula - Cephalic Vein + Radial Artery - joins artery to vein, Thrill + = vibration - fistula working, Mild swelling = fistula site swelling, No redness = no infection. Explain: Sleep disturbed, appetite decreased = uremia.
### 3. Apply - Application to Patient Care
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Diagnosis - CKD on dialysis - given in HOPI.
- AV Fistula Examination done.
- But no student plan - no investigation plan, no management plan - only what others did.
- No application of acute urine ↓ + breathlessness + swelling to care - no urgent dialysis, no fluid restriction.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial application - dialysis + fistula exam applied, but no care plan.
- *Next target:* Add: CBC - Hb - Pallor +, RFT - urea, creatinine, eGFR, Electrolytes - K, Na, Ca, Phosphate, ABG, ECG, Chest X-ray - pulmonary edema, USG abdomen - kidney size. Add management - Urgent dialysis - acute on chronic - urine ↓ + breathlessness + swelling = fluid overload, do not miss dialysis, fluid restriction, low salt, daily weight, check BP daily, check fistula daily - thrill / bruit, keep clean, no BP / blood draw on fistula arm, treat anaemia - iron, erythropoietin, treat HTN - BP control, monitor SOB, edema, urine, sleep, appetite, refer - Nephrology. Add: If BP 160/90 + SOB + SpO2 94% - urgent - check lungs for crepitations, check for pulmonary edema.
### 4. Analyze - Differentiation & Interpretation
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Diagnosis - CKD on dialysis - given, but no differential list.
- No analysis of alternative causes: CKD vs Heart failure vs Liver failure vs Nephrotic syndrome.
- No analysis of acute deterioration causes: Missed dialysis vs Infection vs HTN vs Anaemia vs Heart failure.
- No analysis of pallor + edema + SOB - CKD vs anaemia vs heart failure - not differentiated.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial analysis - CKD acute-on-chronic pattern recognized, but not differentiated.
- *Next target:* Add differential table: CKD Stage 5 on Dialysis, Acute on Chronic - supports 26M, CKD 3 years, HTN 3 years, dialysis 1.5 years, urine ↓ 2 days, breathlessness 3 days, swelling 3 days, oliguria 200 ml/day, Pallor +, Edema +, BP 160/90, SpO2 94%; against - no RFT, eGFR, USG kidney given, cause of CKD unknown, last dialysis unknown. Heart Failure - supports SOB, edema, HTN; against - no chest pain, productive cough, S1 S2 normal, RS NVBS, no basal crepitations mentioned. Liver Failure - supports edema, appetite ↓; against - no jaundice, ascites, Icterus absent, P/A soft. Nephrotic Syndrome - supports edema, HTN; against - no frothy urine, no urine protein mentioned. Must analyze: Why acute deterioration in 2-3 days - missed dialysis? Infection? HTN? Anaemia? Is Pallor + due to CKD anaemia or blood loss?
### 5. Evaluate - Judgment & Reflection
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- PICCLE - Pallor +, Edema + - shows judgment - you correctly recorded pallor + edema, unlike Case 1 where PICCLE was "No abnormality".
- AV Fistula Examination - Thrill +, Mild swelling, No redness - shows judgment - fistula working, not infected.
- Negatives - No fever, productive cough, chest pain, No hematuria - show judgment.
- But no judgment on BP 160/90, SpO2 94%, acute urine ↓ + breathlessness - not flagged as urgent.
- No reflection.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial evaluation - PICCLE + fistula + negatives show judgment, but vitals / acute deterioration judgment missing.
- *Next target:* Add: Can I label CKD Stage 5 without eGFR / USG? What is most urgent - urine ↓ 2 days + breathlessness 3 days + swelling 3 days + BP 160/90 + SpO2 94% - is he in fluid overload / pulmonary edema / hypertensive emergency? What is the risk if I miss pulmonary edema / hyperkalaemia / severe anaemia in a 26M on dialysis with acute deterioration? What would I do differently - check BP, Pulse, SpO2, RR, lungs for crepitations, check weight gain, check last dialysis, check fistula bruit, ask about missed dialysis, orthopnoea / PND? Reflection on 26M businessman - 3 years CKD, 1.5 years dialysis 2 times/week - impact on business, family, daily life, diet - salt / fluid restriction, dialysis burden, anaemia - weakness?
### 6. Create - Synthesis & New Learning Product
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- No original product - no algorithm, concept map, patient education material, Socratic questions - unlike Case 1 where Socratic questions were started.
*Score: 0 / 2*
- Not met.
- *Next target:* Create 1-page algorithm: Young Adult with CKD on Dialysis + Acute Breathlessness + Swelling + ↓ Urine -> Missed Dialysis vs Fluid Overload vs Heart Failure -> Examination -> RFT + Chest X-ray + AV Fistula Check -> Urgent Dialysis, OR patient education sheet for CKD on Dialysis - AV Fistula Care, fluid / salt, BP monitoring, when to go to hospital - breathlessness, swelling, urine ↓, OR Socratic questions like Case 1 - Why does CKD cause pallor? Why does urine fall? Why does fistula have thrill?
### Summary Sheet - Roll No. 12 - 2023 Batch
Bloom Level | Score /2 | Key Feedback
1. Remember | 2 | Timeline + acute on chronic + PICCLE + fistula complete, pitting contradiction
2. Understand | 1 | Acute on chronic described, CKD mechanism not explained
3. Apply | 1 | Dialysis + fistula applied, no urgent dialysis plan
4. Analyze | 1 | CKD acute-on-chronic recognized, no differential table
5. Evaluate | 1 | PICCLE + fistula show judgment, BP 160/90 / SpO2 94% missed
6. Create | 0 | No original product
**Total** | **6 / 12** | **Developing - Competent**
*Overall CBME Feedback for Roll 12 - Progression:*
- CASE 1 CKD 49F = 7/12, *This portfolio = 6/12*
- *Progress flat, but PICCLE is better:* In Case 1 you wrote PICCLE "No abnormality" despite edema, here you correctly wrote Pallor Present (+) and Edema Present (+) - Pedal edema, pitting - that is a real improvement. Acute on chronic - urine ↓ 2 days, breathlessness 3 days, swelling 3 days on CKD 3 years + dialysis 1.5 years - is a textbook fluid overload story, and you captured it. AV Fistula - Thrill +, Mild swelling, No redness - is again good.
- *Critical learning from this case:* You have a contradiction - HOPI "non-pitting" vs PICCLE "pitting" - CKD edema is pitting, fix it. And you missed Pulse - in CKD + breathlessness + HTN, Pulse is essential. And you recorded BP 160/90, SpO2 94%, Pallor +, urine 200 ml/day but did not flag them - in a 26M on dialysis with acute breathlessness + swelling + urine ↓, those are red flags for fluid overload / pulmonary edema. Add Pulse + Bruit + RFT + Hb + last dialysis + Socratic questions / algorithm like Case 1, and this case becomes 8-9/12.
For patient centered CBME online learning portfolio assessment methodology details and further reading please click here:

No comments:
Post a Comment