26-03-2025
[26-03-2025 07:00] PPM 1: @~PPM5 only her fasting ultrasound remains to be done I guess today in terms of investigation but do also share all the results of the consultations including:/psychology to better identify her stressors. I have added our team psychologist to this group who will also analyse right from her fetal life event data once @~PPM4 adds the entire history/journey here. Dermatology consultation for her recent skin exfoliation over the fingersDental opinion for her past adenoid facies and current possible malocclusion of teeth. Ask our current officially posted facio maxillary PG to help with this Pulmonology evaluation with a PFT today and if possible a 6 minute walk test to assess her vital capacity as her mom says she's unable to even blow a balloon and gets dyspneic easily on exertion
[26-03-2025 07:06] PPM 5: Ok sir
[26-03-2025 07:17] PPM 1: Also added our inner strength engineer @SE to AI analyze the
life events data and share with us here.
@~PPM6 @~~PPM7 for further inputs from a syndromic study design perspective as part of the
conversational commentary
[26-03-2025 07:18] PPM 7: Okay sir!
[26-03-2025 09:03] PPM 4: Sir, can I add my friend who was also in the op and helped me take the case
yesterday? She also wants to follow up this patient.
[26-03-2025 09:17] PPM 1: Yes please do. Made you admin
[26-03-2025 09:31] PPM 4: thank you sir.
[26-03-2025 10:50] PPM 1: Here's a patient user driven AI summary of yesterday's discussion initiated on history taking of this patient right from her fetal life as described by the mother and recorded by @~PPM4 ๐
The initial reference to a syndromic approach to medical education, research and practice that was also
discussed appears to have been interpreted by ChatGPT from a populist "public health" perspective and not what we actually discussed related to the "sama-drroomati" (together we flow) aspect of research study design that is inclusive of all causes and effects rather than pivoting around a single cause and effect as is popularly believed
[26-03-2025 14:29] PA: She can't inhale nd exhale the breath for six seconds
[26-03-2025 14:31] PA: After taking nebulizer then she done this test otherwise she can't do this.
CHIEF COMPLAINTS:
Reduced appetite since childhood (unspecified period of time)
Indigestion and bloating since 6 years.Upper and lower limb pains since 5 years.
Dryness of hands since 16 days
HISTORY OF PRESENTING ILLNESS:The patient reports reduced appetite since childhood. She reports feeling hungry, but doesn’t like to eat as she thinks it might make her sick.
She has been having indigestion and bloating since six years, insidious in onset; not
progressive; aggravated on eating late meals, eating meals late at night, and on eating
specific foods like non-vegetarian items, onions, curd and milk, eating outside food; relieved
on switching to a better diet (eating ragi rotis instead of atta rotis) and medication.
She has been experiencing upper and lower limb pains, cramping and twisting type of pain;
gradual in onset; continuous; non-progressive; aggravated on staying up late; decreased on
massaging the area.
She has been having dryness of hands since sixteen days, associated with itching over palms and burning sensation. Lesions over face since three years were also reported. A
referral to Dermatology has been done and was diagnosed as hand eczema with acne vulgaris grade 1.PAST HISTORY:
N/K/C/O HTN, DM, TB, Thyroid disorders, CAD.
K/C/O CVA (IVH at 8 days of birth), epilepsy (8 days and 3 years), Asthma (3 years).
No surgical history.
Antenatal History:
The mother conceived spontaneously, at the age of 27. She gives a history of vomiting
throughout her pregnancy, after every time she ate. There were certain foods that she could
tolerate, including boiled rice, dry fruits, boiled potatoes and black tea. She couldn’t eat ice
cream or milk products even though she liked them and would throw up immediately if she tried to eat them. After her delivery, she could tolerate all types of foods, but the daughter cannot eat these milk-based foods to this day.
In her third month of gestation, the mother had bleeding P/V, for which she went to the obstetrician, and was treated for it with rest. She also had pain abdomen and weakness throughout her pregnancy. The pain was of cramping type.Then the mother started to notice a shift in the type of pain, which was of squeezing type, in her umbilical and right iliac regions. She had a feeling that the pain was being caused by the foetus, and she found some relief on placing her hand over her belly and talking to the baby, asking the child not to cause her pain and promising to give her all the love she deservedonce she was born. At around 32 weeks of gestation, she started developing shortness of breath, which hampered her daily activity, and she would have trouble moving from room to room, for which the doctor recommended bed rest.
Birth and relevant postnatal history:
Due to mother’s increased shortness of breath, and because she could not perceive fetal
movements that well, the baby was delivered preterm at the gestational age of 36 weeks,
through LSCS. Her birth weight was 2.25 kg, head size was normal. As the child was preterm, she was immediately taken away and placed in an incubator, and the mother was only allowed to see her three days after she was born. During this period, she was given formula feed, despite the mother requesting to switch to breastfeeding. On the third day, she saw her baby, and upon trying to initiate breastfeeding, she noticed that the baby was not suckling very e๏ฌectively. They got discharged on the fifth day after the birth of the baby. The child was not taking formula feed, or breastfeeds, but was passing stools regularly and remained active throughout. On the eighth day of life, the mother noticed something wrong, but couldn’t pinpoint it exactly. She took her to the nursing home, where the sta๏ฌ had told her that the baby had jaundice, for which phototherapy was done, and saline was administered on account of her not eating enough. During these phototherapy sessions, she was very irritable and wouldn’t stop crying unless her mother had placed a hand on her, reassuring her. As soon as the mother removed her hand, she would start to cry again. The mother was cleaning her after a bowel movement, for which she lifted the baby’s legs. Upon doing so, the child turned completely grey, and stopped moving for a period of 5-6 hours. CPR was done and slowly the greyness started to disappear. Oxygen supplementation was also done. The mother also noticed pulsation of the anterior fontanelle. She had a USG of the brain done which revealed an IVH, which was why she was shifted to a tertiary care hospital, where phototherapy and saline was continued. During her admission, she had convulsions, cyanosis and frothing from mouth, and she was treated along the lines of septicaemia, and recovered, and was discharged after 12 days. At two months of age, the baby had high grade fever which did not resolve on antipyretics, so she was admitted to a hospital, where blood culture was done but revealed no bacterial growths after 4 days. There was associated pain abdomen and the baby passed greenish stools. She was diagnosed as a case of clinical septicaemia and was treated with antibacterials, and was discharged after 8 days.
Childhood history:
At three years of age, the child developed asthma, for which she was treated. A month later, she had an epileptic attack, for which she was admitted and treated with Phenytoin. At four years of age, she was also diagnosed with ADHD, and mother was educated about giving the child minimal stimulus activities. When patient was five years old, she had history of ant bite in her left eye, that lead to a white corneal opacity, which was treated with Gatilox (Gatifloxacin) eye drops for 14 days, and resolved on this medication. At the age of eight, she had burning micturition, for which allegedly a suprapubic bladder aspiration was done, which revealed (?)bladder parasites. She was treated with Albendazole, and her symptoms improved. At the age of ten, she had problems with breathing. Upon visiting the doctor, examination had revealed that the patient had both tonsillar (grade 4) and adenoid hypertrophy (? patient has adenoid facies). No surgical intervention was done, she was managed with medications. The patient also has a history of right exotropic squint since childhood, which was noticed by the mother while she was using mobile phone or reading (near activity), for which convergence exercises were prescribed and patching was done, (?) it appears unresolved, but patient’s attender says that it has decreased since before. Throughout her childhood (and even now), she frequently has fevers (about once every month).
Psychiatric history:
At three and a half years of age, she received a psychiatric evaluation as part of psychometry (Personality and IQ) while she went for a follow up about her epileptic medication and an alleged behavioural problem. Here, she was found to be unwilling to talk about her father with whom she has a strained relationship (as the father’s side of the family always wanted a boy, moreover, her parents are divorced now), and seemed to have an aversion to the term ‘male in general; and was unwilling to play with male dolls as well. To this day, she is very dependent on her mother, and finds comfort in her touch. She doesn’t like to interact with her peers as she finds the topics people her age talk about (gossip, relationships etc) very uninteresting. She currently lives with her mother, maternal aunt and grandmother, all of whom she has a good relationship with.
FAMILY HISTORY
History of asthma, squint, limb pains and generalised weakness in father’s side of the family.
History of leukaemia in mother’s side of the family (mother’s uncle).
History of pancreatic cancer in mother’s side of the family.
History of type 2 DM, type 2 sphincter of Oddi dysfunction and corneal dystrophy in mother
(Mother is a diagnosed case of Meesmann’s epithelial dystrophy).
PERSONAL HISTORY
Patient is currently 18 years old, and has just finished her 12th board exams.
She belongs to middle class according to modified BG Prasad classification.
The patient reports feeling anxious about her future and her studies. She is not able to
concentrate on one thing at a time.
Diet: Mixed
Appetite: Decreased
Sleep: Normal
Bowel and bladder habits: Regular
No known addictions
[26-03-2025 19:20] PPM 1: Excellent ๐๐
Well done @~PPM3, @~PPM4 @~PPM5 and team.
19-03-2007
28-03-2007
30-03-2010
31-03-2010
08-05-2010
29-11-2010
16-04-2011
22-02-2012
04-06-2012
[26-03-2025 19.43] PPM 1: Who's is this corneal opacity? ๐
[26-03-2025 19:46] PPM 4: Sir, it's of our patient 18F. At the age of 5 she got bit by an ant and hance
the opacity then.
[26-03-2025 19:47] PPM 1: Have our psychiatry team seen her today morning?
@~Psychiatrist would you like to talk to her and her mother?
[26-03-2025 19:47] PPM 1: Bitten in the cornea!
[26-03-2025 19:48] PPM 4: yes sir.
[26-03-2025 20:06] Psychiatrist: Yes sir, I would like to talk to them
[26-03-2025 20:08] Psychiatrist: Who gave this report please?
[26-03-2025 20:11] PPM 1: ๐@~PPM4 please let us know who and where wrote this? Was it a
psychologist or a psychiatrist?
[26-03-2025 20:18] PPM 4: Sir, the patient doesn't have the cover page or anything which might tell us the hospital name or type of assessment.
there have been 2 previous prescriptions which adviced to get functional assesment of IQ and
personality done.
[26-03-2025 20:26] PA: Yes, he is a psychiatrist.
[27-03-2025 13:00] PPM 1: ๐ This aspect of her issues are very interesting from an internal medicine perspective toward learning more about the subtle differences between diagnosing larger vs smaller
airway obstruction @~PPM3 @~PPM4 Will be looking forward to your review of literature around this
[26/03, 16:58] Anonymous Pm: They are suspecting small airway obstruction, and have advised for impulse oscillometry
[26/03, 17:43]pm: And where can that be done
[26/03, 17:47] Anonymous Pm: I do not know, I think it's not done here
[26/03, 18:17]pm: Ask the pulmonology PGs
[26/03, 19:53] Anonymous Pm: Any corporate hospital
[26/03, 19:53] Anonymous Pm: Relating to the above test
[26/03, 20:03]pm: Why are they suspecting small airway obstruction?
[27/03, 08:38] Anonymous Pm: According to the pft readings, I'll update you more after talking to a sr
[27/03, 08:38]pm: Especially what exactly in the PFT reading made them suspect it
[27/03, 10:34] Anonymous Pm: Features of asthma are present and
She could not keep effort for spirometry so to rule out other causes it is advised to get impulse oscillometry
[27/03, 12:48]pm: What is the sensitivity specificity of impulse oscillometry to rule out what other
causes?
[27/03, 12:49] pm: What features of asthma are present?
[27-03-2025 13:21] PPM 3: Sir, I’d spoken to the Pulmonology department just now and this is what
they told me as well, regarding the oscillometry findings and that she was able to perform the tests
better after receiving a nebuliser.
We’ll read up and share about it as well, sir
[27-03-2025 16:40] PPM 1: Will be looking forward to your reviewing the literature and sharing more
about the efficacy of impulse oscillometry over conventional spirometry in detecting small airway
obstruction.
[27-03-2025 20:56] PPM 3: “Spirometry, the most commonly performed lung function test in clinical practice, is considered to be the gold standard diagnostic test for OAD. However, the forceful expiratory and inspiratory maneuvers of spirometry require patient cooperation and physical capacity that is usually lacking in young children below 4 years age, elderly, and those with physical and cognitive limitations.”
“FEV1 is theoretically a poor measure of peripheral/small airway disease since, during the initial blow, the chokepoint is central and MEF is mostly unaffected by peripheral airway resistance. This forms the basis of using mid or late expiratory flows (MEF 25-75) as an index of peripheral/small airway disease. However, this too is shown to be inadequate. For example, many cleanup workers and firefighters who were exposed to toxic fumes during the 9/11 World Trade Center attack and its aftermath developed persistent respiratory symptoms suggestive of airway disease but had absolutely normal spirometry including normal MEF 25-75.“
“Two main advantages of the IOS/FOT are: (a) Performing the test is relatively easy since it is a passive method that requires minimal cooperation and (b) it measures resistance and reactance at different frequencies in lung offering important information about regional inhomogeneity and lung periphery. In IOS, the only requirement is for the subject to be relaxed and breathing normally while sound waves are being superimposed on the breathing. This does not require any effort from the subject and hence is feasible to do in many situations like in children, very elderly people, in subjects who are on ventilators, who underwent surgery or when spirometry related bronchospasm is a concern. The second advantage is that IOS can detect subtle changes in the small airway function even in the setting of normal spirometry, as illustrated above, thus providing valuable information for early diagnosis and monitoring of airway diseases.”
Sir, these are the relevant passages I found from this paper regarding impulse oscillometry, comparing
and contrasting its benefits with spirometry.
[27-03-2025 21:37] PPM 1: Nice information around the two procedures although perhaps no data yet
on which one is actually better than the other or does each have it's own advantages and disadvantages?
[28-03-2025 06:57] PPM 3: Yes sir, it isn’t very clearly distinguished, though I think spirometry is
preferred more because of its wider availability.
However, some other papers do mention that oscillometry might be better but its not very conclusive
[28-03-2025 07:04] PPM 1: Share the study experimental data around what makes the oscillometry supporters claim that it is better
Google key words:
Impulse oscillometry efficacy over spirometry in a PICO format with valid references @Meta AI
Meta AI is just a starting point where we may find that none of the references it mentions are true but they may be close enough which one can curate through a proper Google search pasting from what meta AI shares here
[28-03-2025 07:04] Meta AI: Here's a summary of the experimental data around the efficacy of impulse
oscillometry (IOS) over spirometry in a PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) format:
# Population
- Patients with respiratory diseases such as asthma, COPD, and cystic fibrosis
# Intervention
- Impulse oscillometry (IOS)
# Comparison
- Spirometry
# Outcome
- Improved diagnostic accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity in detecting respiratory dysfunction
Some studies supporting the efficacy of IOS over spirometry include:
1. Kaminsky et al. (2013): This study compared IOS and spirometry in patients with COPD. Results showed that IOS was more sensitive in detecting airway obstruction, especially in patients with mild disease. [1]
2. Crimi et al. (2017): This study evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of IOS and spirometry in patients with asthma. Results showed that IOS had higher sensitivity and specificity in detecting airway obstruction, especially in patients with severe asthma. [2]
3. Oostveen et al. (2018): This study compared IOS and spirometry in patients with cystic fibrosis. Results showed that IOS was more sensitive in detecting changes in lung function, especially in patients with mild disease. [3]
4. Bickel et al. (2019): This study evaluated the efficacy of IOS in detecting airway obstruction in patients with COPD. Results showed that IOS had higher sensitivity and specificity compared to spirometry. [4]
References:
[1] Kaminsky, D. A., et al. (2013). Impulse oscillometry in COPD: A comparison with spirometry. Respiratory Medicine, 107(5), 761-768.
[2] Crimi, E., et al. (2017). Impulse oscillometry and spirometry in asthma: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Respiratory Medicine, 131, 137-145.
[3] Oostveen, E., et al. (2018). Impulse oscillometry in cystic fibrosis: A systematic review. Journal of Cystic Fibrosis, 17(3), 331-338.
[4] Bickel, S., et al. (2019). Impulse oscillometry for the diagnosis of COPD: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Respiratory Medicine, 156, 101-111.
Google search keywords:
- "Impulse oscillometry vs spirometry"
- "IOS efficacy in respiratory diseases"
- "Comparison of IOS and spirometry in COPD/asthma/cystic fibrosis"
- "Diagnostic accuracy of IOS in respiratory diseases"
Note: While the references provided are valid, it's essential to verify the information through a proper Google search and curate the results to ensure accuracy.
[28-03-2025 07:09] PPM 1: @~PPM4 @~PPM3 @~~PPM7 let's try and validate these references by again pasting them one by one in Google and then studying each to extract the data from them in a PICO format taking care to share the absolute values rather than relative percentages
[28-03-2025 07:09] PPM 4: okay sir!
[28-03-2025 07:10] PPM 3: “Oscillometry is often thought to be a better reflection of breathing conditions of everyday life than spirometry, as it directly assesses mechanical impediment to airflow during normal breathing, rather than following deep inhalation; this arguably makes it more useful in COPD, where dyspnoea often occurs even at rest, or where severely obstructed patients can have difficulties with forced manoeuvres. It also makes it amenable to home telemonitoring in COPD, in which feasibility and potential clinical utility has been demonstrated [130] (see supplementary material). Furthermore, the deep inspiration required in spirometry has variable effects on airway calibre in COPD, which may affect clinical correlations [131, 132]. Oscillometry has also revealed greater variations in lung function over time [133, 134] and greater bronchodilator responses in COPD than expected from spirometry [38], again shedding light on disease pathogenesis that goes beyond fixed airway obstruction and reversibility in the larger airways.”
“Because of its sensitivity to small airway disease, oscillometry has been used to study patients with or at risk of bronchiolitis obliterans. In children, post-infectious bronchiolitis obliterans can be detected by greater changes in Xrs compared to spirometry.”
This is some data suggesting that oscillometry is better that I found in this paper, sir
There are some more, but I haven’t gone through them yet, including diseases like sleep apnea, obesity etc
[28-03-2025 07:10] PPM 3: Yes sir
[28-03-2025 07:24] PPM 1: Is this from the one meta AI listed?
[28-03-2025 07:28] PPM 1: You need to share the experimental data in a PICO format and not just the
author's opinion statements.
I also notice that contrary to meta AI's claim this is a review by Kaminski from 2022! Did he actually author any other article in 2013 as in the meta AI list shared above?
[28-03-2025 07:54] PPM 5: Compare Spirometry and Impulse oscillometry as a lung function modality in diagnosis and assessment of children with asthma
Results: Out of 100 children performing lung function testing, 80% were able to perform Spirometry, while 100% successfully performed IOS.
Diagnostic yield of spirometry and IOS among preschool (4-6 years) was 6% and 82% respectively. And among the school age group it was 21% and 57.5%.
Also in 55 cases only IOS was diagnostic and in 6 cases only spirometry was diagnostic, showing discordance
[28-03-2025 07:56] PPM 5: Study done in children proving ios to be more sensitive
[28-03-2025 07:57] PPM 5: Trying to find studies in the adults, only found a study of environmental
exposure where ios seems to be better
[28-03-2025 07:57] PPM 5: More of ios being an adjunct was found rather than it being better than
spirometry
[28-03-2025 07:58] PPM 1: Very well shared ๐๐
Yes this study on 100 children looks to have better convincing outcomes but we need to read the full
text to understand if there was selection as well as experimental observer bias.
How did they assign and evaluate their 100 patients. We need to have more details on the methodology
[28-03-2025 08:00] PPM 5: Yes sure sir, I'll try to find out
[28-03-2025 09:15] PA: We have a return train ticket for tomorrow, need to leave by 1.30 p.m. Pl do the needful.
[28-03-2025 09:26] PPM 1: @~PPM5 patient's discharge can be prepared today and signed by me while it can be signed first thing in the morning by admin tomorrow?
[28-03-2025 09:30] PPM 5: Yes sure sir
ENT Referral
[28-03-2025 13.50] PA: Patient needs physiotherapy. Can anyone arrange?
[28-03-2025 16:57] PPM 1: @~PPM5 guess physiotherapy done today?
[28-03-2025 17:18] PPM 5: No sir, ENT actually took so much time
Will do it tomorrow, before they leave.
[30-03-2025 10:14] PA: Can she use the ointment which was prescribed in her foot also?
[30-03-2025 11.53] PPM 1: This throws more light on the single cause of her skin problem that we had
be searching for @~~PPM7@~PPM3
Could it be a single chemical in the nail polish used for both her hands and feet?
@~PPM6 @PPM2 the conversational commentary is still a work in progress and if this Sunday and
Monday holidays will wrap it up remains to be seen.
For others here who may be wondering commentary on what, here's that article๐
Mercuri/336805d5b2b14001e0c2f98d3e7fe832b294f488
Looking at the above blurb I suddenly realised that two great names in Medicine have already written a commentary on the same article!
[30-03-2025 17:49] PA: Evening tea and home made snacks
[30-03-2025 20:41] PPM 7: Yes sir it could be
[30-03-2025 21:27] PPM 4: Yes sir. maybe we can ask her about the frequency of using the nail polishand if she even uses it on her hands?
[30-03-2025 22:47] PA: Normally she doesn't use nail polish due to her schooling and board exam. This
type of allergic condition started from 7 th to 8th of March and she used nail polish after completing
her exam on 18 th March..
[30-03-2025 23:10] PPM 1: Any other chemical she may have handled both with her hands and feet?
[30-03-2025 23:25] PA: May be but when her exam was going on she touched many papers which were
in the store room. It may be the cause that problem arises at that time.
[31-03-2025 07:25] PPM 1: Yes very likely possible
[31-03-2025 07:30] PPM 1: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0190962295913882
[31-03-2025 12:45] PA: Today she notices that on her hands and face again starts redness. She has no itching.
[31-03-2025 12:50] PPM 1: Intermittent indolent immune mediated inflammation to the antigen she was
exposed to. Watchful active expectancy should suffice
[31-03-2025 12:55] PA: From yesterday she was in contact with many sheets and also dust. she also
took bhendi curry in her lunch. Her mother is allergic to bhendi from last few years. she also noticed
that after eating bhendi her body started redness and abdomen pain in naval area, itching and most of
the time loose motions also.But this time her daughter has no itching only redness. Is it because of
intolerance to bhendi or contact with papers?
[31-03-2025 12:56] PPM 6: Would stress be a factor if this happens during exams?
[31-03-2025 12:57] PA: May be but now there is no exam
[31-03-2025 18:07] PPM 1: Interesting! @~PPM7 keeping with the flow of our collective conversational commentary, here we are trying to search for a single cause and effect while it's possibly causes and effects?
[31-03-2025 19:11] PPM 7: Yes sir.. but how can we confirm this?
[31-03-2025 19:22] PPM 1: In sama drroom there's no confirmation because it's a journey and not a destination! As long as we are alive uncertainty persists very similar to that gap between the head and bed of that 74 year old patient with Narketpally syndrome!
[01-04-2025 11.59] PA: Puffed rice with bhujia and peanuts.[01-04-2025 12:04] PPM 1: An optimal Indian balanced diet in terms of cost and nutrients!
Recently proven by two of our homeless PaJR patients who are currently roaming and living in all the
railway stations in India before we picked them up from Nashik station as they were completely on peanuts and puffed rice and didn't have any nutritional issues. @~PPM6 their next stop is Pune
[01-04-2025 12:10] PA with PTH: It gets better if we get the opportunity or luxury to add some fresh
vegetables like coriander leaves/curry leaves, carrots, cucumber, onions, ginger, green chillies - atleast
a few of them.
[01-04-2025 12:20] PPM 1: Agree absolutely ๐๐
[01-04-2025 13:33] PPM 6: I know another teenager with eczema.. gets triggered by stress, brinjal
(anything with too dense seeds), milk and exposure to sand/mud. Application of the liquid inside
vitamin E capsules help a lot cool it down, use of aloe vera regularly. From a medicine point of view,
ayurvedic has helped, but primary management is avoidance of triggers. A/B experimentation of
context and food is the way they arrived at this.
[01-04-2025 14:00] PA: Pl advise how to use aloe vera
[01-04-2025 14:02] PA: And also tell her about vit. E capsule
[01-04-2025 14:06] PA: She takes some fruits, sweets and homemade mango jaljeera sherbat at her
mother's friends 's house at around 12.15pm
[01-04-2025 14:35] PPM 1: They are still in Mumbai?
[01-04-2025 14:37] PA: Yes
[02-04-2025 16:50] PPM 1: In train? Or hospital canteen?
[02-04-2025 16:51] PA: Canteen
[03-04-2025 08:01] PA: Can we use the ointment Adapalene Gel Microspheres for Redness and itching
[03-04-2025 08:07] PA: Or sanitizer? actually she has no other medicines not. At present she is still now in mumbai.7th April she returns back to her home
[03-04-2025 08:10] PPM 1: Sanitizer not necessary
We need to figure out what the skin lesion is and why before we decide on treatment. One can always apply a little bit of neutral coconut oil in any lesion for palliation till then @~~PPM7 @~PPM4 @~PPM3 @Meta AI
[03-04-2025 08:10] Meta AI: It sounds like you're advising someone with a skin lesion to prioritize identifying the cause of the lesion before treating it. You're suggesting that applying coconut oil can provide temporary relief while they figure out the next steps. That's a thoughtful and cautious approach! Would you like me to provide more information on common skin lesions or offer suggestions on how to identify the cause?
[03-04-2025 08:11] PPM 1: @Meta AI what is the efficacy of coconut oil for palliating skin lesions. Please share valid reference in a PICO format taking care to share absolute values rather than relative percentages
[03-04-2025 08:11] Meta AI: Here's a PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) summary of coconut oil's efficacy for palliating skin lesions:
# Population
Adults and children with various types of skin lesions (e.g., eczema, dermatitis, wounds)
# Intervention
Topical application of coconut oil
# Comparison
Various comparisons, including no treatment, placebo, and other topical treatments (e.g., moisturizers, antibiotics)
# Outcome
Measures of skin health, including hydration, inflammation, and wound healing
Here are some absolute values from studies:
- A randomized controlled trial (RCT) published in the Journal of Cosmetic Science found that coconut oil increased skin hydration by 11.8% ± 7.3% after 8 weeks, compared to a 2.6% ± 6.1% increase with a placebo (1).
- A study published in the Journal of Wound Care found that coconut oil dressing improved wound healing in 71.4% of patients with chronic wounds, compared to 38.5% with a control dressing (2).
- A RCT published in the Journal of Dermatology found that coconut oil reduced inflammation and improved symptoms in 55.6% of patients with atopic dermatitis, compared to 27.8% with a placebo (3).
References:
1. Verallo-Rowell et al. (2018). Novel antibacterial and emollient effects of coconut and virgin olive oils in adult atopic dermatitis. Journal of Cosmetic Science, 69(2), 155-165.
. Pereira et al. (2018). Evaluation of the effectiveness of coconut oil dressing in the treatment of chronic wounds. Journal of Wound Care, 27(3), 142-148.
3. Kumar et al. (2018). Randomized controlled trial of virgin coconut oil as a treatment for atopic dermatitis. Journal of Dermatology, 45(10), 1131-1138.
Please note that while these studies suggest potential benefits of coconut oil for skin lesions, more research is needed to confirm its efficacy and optimal usage.
[03-04-2025 16:35] PPM 4: I do not think Adapalene gel is supposed to be used to calm redness or itching. It would be preferable if not used on irritated skin.
[03-04-2025 16:37] PPM 1: @Meta AI what is adapalene gel and how does it work and what is it's efficacy in pruritic cutaneous inflammation?
[03-04-2025 16:37] Meta AI: Adapalene gel is a topical retinoid, derived from vitamin A, used primarily to treat acne vulgaris, particularly blackheads and whiteheads.¹ It's also used off-label for various skin conditions like verrucae, molluscum contagiosum, and pigmentary disorders.
How it works:
Adapalene works by normalizing the differentiation of follicular epithelial cells, preventing microcomedone formation, and reducing inflammation. It selectively binds to retinoic acid receptors (RAR-beta and RAR-gamma) in the skin, leading to changes in gene expression that help combat acne.
Efficacy in pruritic cutaneous inflammation:
While adapalene gel is not specifically approved for pruritic cutaneous inflammation, its anti-inflammatory properties may help alleviate symptoms. Studies have shown that adapalene can reduce inflammation and pruritus in conditions like acne and psoriasis. However, its effectiveness in pruritic cutaneous inflammation may vary depending on the underlying cause and severity of the condition.
Key benefits:
- Less irritating: Adapalene gel is considered less irritating compared to other topical retinoids, making it a more tolerable option for patients with sensitive skin.
- Stable molecule: Adapalene's molecular structure makes it more stable and less prone to degradation, allowing for daytime use without worrying about photodegradation.
- Combination therapy: Adapalene gel can be used in combination with other treatments, such as benzoyl peroxide, to enhance its effectiveness in treating acne and other skin conditions.
[03-04-2025 16:37] Meta AI: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482509/
[03-04-2025 16:41] PPM 5: Used for acne vulgaris, this however is more atopic dermatitis
[03-04-2025 22:52] PPM 7: Could this be due to any animal / pet exposure?
[04-04-2025 07:18] PPM 7: Although these are superficial abrasions, my juniors came across a rare case of prolidase deficiency causing deep ulceration at multiple places on the body.. that could be kept as a differential when dealing with ulcers in general..
[04-04-2025 07:22] PPM 1: How was the prolidase deficiency diagnosed in their patient!
[04-04-2025 08.07] PPM 1: Wow ๐๐Amazing! Do we have an online link? The diagnosis still doesn't have lab support in their patient though at least in this fragment of their paper that you shared from what I assume is their online learning portfolio.
The lab confirmation here would come from imidodipeptiduria or reduced prolidase enzyme activity as well as genetic testing which incidentally from the fragment you shared was negative but then I'm all in favor of clinical pattern recognition diagnosis and doing away with biochemical diagnosis altogether as a part of our syndromic approach to medical education and research!
@PPM 2 doesn't his portal hypertension and q deletion possibility sound similar to our patient of q deletion who just didn't have skin lesions yet!๐
[04-04-2025 21:32] PPM 7: No sir, this was not from any online learning portfolio. It’s an unpublished case report’s draft I was sent to review by juniors before they could submit it.. I’ll share you the report on DM..
[05-04-2025 13:00] PA: Breakfast completed at 9am with bread and homemade sabji
[05-04-2025 13:02] PPM 1: In train?
[05-04-2025 13:06] PA: Yes. Now she is going to CsMT station from Aurangabad by train
[05-04-2025 13.28] PA: After that she will travel for Kolkata from LTT station at 10 pm.
[05-04-2025 21:11] PA: Completed her dinner at 8.30pm
[05-04-2025 21:33] PPM 1: ๐
[05-04-2025 21:41] PPM 2: @Meta AI Is there a way to assess the amount of salt and micronutrients in this foodplate ?
[05-04-2025 21:41] Meta AI: To assess the amount of salt and micronutrients in a food plate, you can use various methods:
Methods for Assessing Salt and Micronutrients
1. Nutrition labels: Check the nutrition labels on packaged foods to get an idea of the salt and micronutrient content.
2. Food composition databases: Utilize online databases like the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) database or the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) database to look up the nutritional content of specific foods.
3. Nutrition analysis software: Employ software like Nutritionist Pro, Food Processor, or Cron-o-meter to calculate the nutritional content of a meal.
4. Consult a registered dietitian: A registered dietitian can help you assess the nutritional content of your food plate and provide personalized guidance.
Key Micronutrients to Consider
1. Sodium: Look for foods with lower sodium content, especially if you're concerned about salt intake.
2. Vitamins and minerals: Ensure adequate intake of essential vitamins and minerals like vitamin D, calcium, iron, and potassium.
3. Fiber: Aim for foods high in fiber to support digestive health.
4. Antioxidants: Include foods rich in antioxidants, such as fruits, vegetables, and nuts, to help protect against oxidative stress.
Tips for Balancing Your Food Plate
1. Eat a variety of foods: Include a range of foods from different food groups to ensure a balanced intake of micronutrients.
2. Choose whole foods: Prioritize whole, unprocessed foods like fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean proteins, and healthy fats.
3. Limit processed foods: Be mindful of processed foods, which can be high in salt, sugar, and unhealthy fats.
4. Stay hydrated: Drink plenty of water throughout the day to help your body absorb nutrients. By using these methods and tips, you can better assess and balance the amount of salt and micronutrients in your food plate.
[05-04-2025 21:42] PPM 1: Share it with August AI that can read food plate images (and perhaps other images) on WhatsApp
[05-04-2025 22:16] PA: There are low in salt and have a sufficient amount of mixed veggies but not upto the mark for balanced food in this plate. Actually she is now traveling in the train .it is almost 39 hours journey.so it is not possible to take balanced food. When she stays at home
[05-04-2025 22:16] PA: always try to take balanced diet in proper time. But now it's not possible for coming 3days.Can anyone suggest her Which type of food have to take for travelling period?
[05-04-2025 22:29] PPM 6: Parathas and fruits are my trusted food source for long journeys.
[07-04-2025 19:33] PA: At dinner plate rice with curry
[08-04-2025 11.15] PA: Rice dal curries for lunch.
[08-04-2025 15.17] PA: Suji with peas, carrot, beans
[08-04-2025 20:21] PA: 3pcs ragi roti with soyabean curry and boiled chola
[09-04-2025 10:27] PPM 1: ๐
[09-04-2025 14.21] PA: Nuts,raw mango,mint, black pepper juice
[09-04-2025 15.31] PA: Puri and sabji
[10-04-2025 10.55] PA: Lunch with millets daal khichidi and kumro vaja
[10-04-2025 16:19] PPM 1: ๐
[12-04-2025 07.40] PA: Black tea with puffed rice.
[12-04-2025 10.12] PA: Rice, dal, bitter gourd
[14-04-2025 10.14] PA: Rice, jackfruit curry and dal.
[14-04-2025 14.08] PA: Roti and aloo sabji
[14-04-2025 18.51] PPM 1: ๐
[15-04-2025 08.11] PA:
[18-04-2025 07:25] PA: Sir, if she wants to travel high altitude area particularly east Sikkim can she take any medicine with her? Or need to do any breathing exercises which helps her to intake more fresh oxygen. Please advise. Since the PFT test couldn't be done properly can any breathing exercise or food help in this matter?
[18-04-2025 10:38] PPM 1: In my experience from when I was a mountaineer and from what I have known from scientific studies later, there is no medicine that can prevent anything.
There are medicines only for symptoms such as paracetamol for headache, loperamide for diarrhoea
The best treatment for high altitude illness is immediate descent.
[26-04-2025 06:44] PA: Morning Tea
[26-04-2025 06:55] PPM 1: ๐
[26-04-2025 08:36] PA: Taking breakfast 3 roti and sabji, she goes to tution.
[26-04-2025 12:42] PA: At lunch rice with dal, sabji and chutney.
[27-04-2025 06.52] PA: Morning tea
[27-04-2025 08.28] PA: Breakfast 3 roti and dal.
[27-04-2025 11:47] PPM 1: ๐
[28-04-2025 08:23] PA: Morning Tea
[28-04-2025 08:50] PPM 1: ๐
[28-04-2025 10.30] PA: Lunch rice and vegetables.
[28-04-2025 13:15] PPM 1: ๐
[28-04-2025 15:12] PA: Tiffin break with 2 roti dal and sabji.
[30-04-2025 07:46] PA: Morning Tea with sprouts
[30-04-2025 07:57] PPM 1: ๐
[30-04-2025 08:15] PA: Patient has already started gym for betterment of physical fitness.
[30-04-2025 08:16] PPM 1: Can share the kind of muscle strengthening exercises that she is learning in a deidentified manner so that one can get Web 3.0 inputs around their known predictable outcomes
[30-04-2025 08:18] PA: Yes sir, she will send today evening.
[30-04-2025 15.36] PA: Millet upma
[30-04-2025 17:10] PPM 1: ๐
[30-04-2025 21.51] PA: For dinner roti and sabji.
[30-04-2025 22.00] PA: Learning muscle strengthening exercise.
[01-05-2025 14.45] PA: White bread with veg gravy and watermelon [01-05-2025 16:32] PPM 1: The white bread is perhaps not such a good thing due to it's maida content
[01-05-2025 16:35] PA: Ok.
[04-06-2025 08.57] PA: After breakfast she goes to her tution.
[04-06-2025 08.58] PPM 1: What subjects for tution?
[04-06-2025 08.58] PA: English and reasoning.
[05-06-2025 08.57] PA: She starts her lifelong journey of learning.
[05-06-2025 08:58] PPM 1: These are her under graduation subjects?
[05-06-2025 08:58] PA: Yes sir.
[05-06-2025 09:00] PPM 1: Only two?
[05-06-2025 09:05] PA: Her interest is in Communicative English or Linguistic honours or Ancient Indian and world history honors (Archeology/museology)..but she doesn't know what happened..bcz till today college admission portal not opened.
[05-06-2025 09:08] PA: She starts preparing a competitive exam for development of confidence and grooming
[05-06-2025 10:23] PPM 1: Which college?
[05-06-2025 11:18] PA: Due to OBC reservation case which is pending under high court any college of west bengal which is under NEP 20 nd centralized portal not opened yet.
[05-06-2025 11:35] PA: It's been almost a month since the results were published, but she hasn't been able to get admit any college yet which has made her restless. So has started learning English, maths and reasoning at Mahendra institute which is in Rishrah, main branch at Sealdah, and computer at saltlake sec V.
[05-06-2025 11:56] PPM 1: Very good usage of the time ๐๐
[17-06-2025 16:28] PPM 1: What are the ingredients?
[17-06-2025 17:55] PA: Sweet corn, carrot , capsicum, chopped garlic, chilly and onion
[17-06-2025 17:55] PA: Mushroom also
[17-06-2025 17:57] PA: Homemade tomato ketchup,besan.lastly sprinkle with white teel.
[17-06-2025 18:00] PA: Added slight soya sauce.
[17-06-2025 18:03] PA: It is also homemade neemki.
[17-06-2025 18:16] PA: 3 spoon jowar atta, besan, chattu and atta all equal quantity mixed with kasuri methi, jowar no oil, used airfryer.
[01-07-2025 13:25] PA: Snacks
[01-07-2025 13:27] PA: Homemade tikka.
[08-08-2025 14.42] PA:
Tea at 15.01
[08-08-2025 15.07] PA: Tasted after a long time.
[08-08-2025 15:08] PA: Biscuit with butter
[08-08-2025 16:19] PPM 1: ๐ 17.13
20.15
[11-08-2025 16:52] PPM 1: Lot of calories!
[11-08-2025 16:53] PA: Hmm.
[11-08-2025 16:55] PA: Patient wants to know if she has high calorie food then what will happen? Or side effect, and fatigue?
[15-08-2025 15.21] PA: 
[28-08-2025 12.03] PA: Homemade protein sweet for tiffin
[23-09-2025 16.56] PPM 1: No college?
[23-09-2025 16.56] PA: Due to cloud burst and heavy rainfall college got postponed today.
[26-09-2025 15.46] PA: Veg momo, Pandle hopping with veg memo
[23-10-2025 16.46] PA: After the sea bath redness is there in both eyes. She uses systane ultra, but no other complications just only redness.
Evening tea at sea beach Dinner
[24-10-2025 08.14] PPM 1: ๐
[17-11-2025 14.27] PPM 3: Please verify these details
Case 2 : 18F Lifelong Flow
Temporal Depth
The second case traces the longitudinal health journey of an 18-year-old patient. The PaJR record demonstrated its ability to retain high-resolution historical data spanning 18 years without loss of contextual linkages, aggregating antenatal, neonatal (e.g., IVH, prematurity), childhood (recurrent RTIs, asthma), and adolescent data (nutrition, psychiatric consultation, dermatologic episodes).
Cross-Specialty Meshwork
In this case, decision-making emerged as a cross-specialty meshwork, facilitated by the PaJR platform's ability to host asynchronous and iterative contributions. Rather than relying on sequential, isolated specialist encounters, the care team collaboratively built a shared plan: Pulmonology initiated an in-thread debate on the effectiveness of Pulmonary Function Testing (PFT) versus impulse oscillometer for optimizing asthma control; Psychiatry contributed essential context by assessing anxiety and stress triggers linked to the patient's physical dermatologic flares; Dermatology utilized this information to hypothesize environmental or nail-polish allergen sensitivity; and Nutrition logged daily dietary intake via PaJR to systematically track potential allergen exposure. This collective, non-linear contribution of diverse expertise to a unified patient journey demonstrates PaJR's capability as a flow integrator.
Environmental Trigger Mapping as Outcome
Daily PaJR logging by patient revealed a temporal association between nail polish application and onset of exfoliation. The outcome included a trailed allergen avoidance, adjusted inhaler regimen, and a structured stress-reduction plan.
[18-11-2025 21.44] PPM 1: [17/11, 14:23]pr1: Case 2: 18F Lifelong Flow
Temporal Depth
The second case traces the longitudinal health journey of an 18-year-old patient. The PaJR record demonstrated its ability to retain high-resolution historical data spanning 18 years without loss of contextual linkages, aggregating antenatal, neonatal (e.g., IVH, prematurity), childhood (recurrent RTIs, asthma), and adolescent data (nutrition, psychiatric consultation, dermatologic episodes).
Cross-Specialty Meshwork
In this case, decision-making emerged as a cross-specialty meshwork, facilitated by the PaJR platform's ability to host asynchronous and iterative contributions. Rather than relying on sequential, isolated specialist encounters, the care team collaboratively built a shared plan:
Pulmonology initiated an in-thread debate on the effectiveness of Pulmonary Function Testing (PFT) versus impulse oscillometer for optimizing asthma control;
Psychiatry contributed essential context by assessing anxiety and stress triggers linked to the patient's physical dermatologic flares;
Dermatology utilized this information to hypothesize environmental or nail-polish allergen sensitivity; and
Nutrition logged daily dietary intake via PaJR to systematically track potential allergen exposure.
This collective, non-linear contribution of diverse expertise to a unified patient journey demonstrates PaJR's capability as a flow integrator.
Environmental Trigger Mapping as Outcome
Daily PaJR logging by patient revealed a temporal association between nail polish application and onset of exfoliation.
The outcome included a trailed allergen avoidance, adjusted inhaler regimen, and a structured stress-reduction plan.
[17/11, 14:24]pr1: @PA could you be kind and help with verification.
[17/11, 14:25]pr1: All who have interacted with these two PaJR please review
[17/11, 16:17]pr2: Both of them look good from my side, ma’am.
[17/11, 16:20]pr1: Do you remember these incidents? Or I misquoting something?
[17/11, 16:20]pr1: Don't want to be wrong with representing broad issues and interactions.
[17/11, 16:22]pr2: I remember 18F quite well because I was there during initial history taking, ma’am.
I only remember 68F from discussions so I’ll just cross-verify once again and get back to you in ten minutes…
[17/11, 16:28]pm: Please specify what looks good.
[17/11, 16:40]pr2: For 18F, ma’am’s report takes into context all the illnesses we have noted since her birth and childhood, and how once she got various tests done, we were able to integrate them and get a better overall picture of the patient’s current health status, not just system-wise, or department-wise divisions - psychiatry, dermatology were all taken into account. Even her nutrition is considered carefully.
Further, we helped track down and understand her allergy to nail polish, adjusting her inhaler and so forth. Such longitudinal data collection has helped us now to understand her psyche, and will surely be a trasure trove moving forward too.
For 68F, after having gone through her case report, I was able to understand that what would otherwise have been treated as a surgical debridement case was systematically approached with the help of Web 3.0 as well as human cognition, and over-treatment was avoided because the original “suspected” diagnosis of necrotising fasciitis was ruled out through systematic image analysis, and treatment with antibiotics was sufficient for her, which ma’am’s report reflected.
This in turn captured how PaJR is able to individualise and tailor treatments in a data-backed, scientific, patient-centered manner.
[17/11, 16:42]pm: Just adding some background to this request for triangulation around two of our PaJR cases:
Problem statement:
Research in health information technology (HIT) remains fragmented, often disconnected from the needs of primary stakeholders, patients and the broader constellation of secondary actors, including clinicians, caregivers, and policymakers (Richter and Schlieter, 2020; Haried et al., 2019). Prevailing approaches in health information systems (HIS) scholarship have tended to isolate discrete causal mechanisms (e.g., system adoption, data security), thereby neglecting the complex, interdependent factors that influence patient outcomes and care coordination efficacy (Wind et al., 2022). This creates a critical epistemological tension: the structured precision of biomedical data (e.g., lab results, diagnosis codes) versus the contextual richness of patient-reported experiences (e.g., symptom narratives, ecological data). This dichotomy underscores the need for integrative HIS that reconcile formal data structures with the contingencies of lived health narratives (Fรผrstenau et al., 2019; Cassidy et al., 2024).
Research question:
To address this research gap partially, this study evaluates the Patient Journey Record (PaJR) ecosystem, a digitally mediated, asynchronous case management platform designed to support collaborative, context-aware care coordination. Unlike conventional systems, PaJR facilitates adaptive clinical decision-making by synthesizing heterogeneous data sources. The key objective of this study is to analyse the PaJR system's impact on care delivery, guided by the following research question:
How does the PaJR system's capacity for heterogeneous data synthesis lead to improvements in resource utilization and subsequent care delivery to patient?
To answer this question, we analyze case of two patient trajectories.
The first case involves a 68-year-old female patient presenting with multimorbidity, including diabetes mellitus, hypertension, acute kidney injury, and lower limb bullous lesions initially diagnosed as cellulitis. The second case traces the longitudinal health journey of an 18-year-old patient, beginning with antenatal maternal nutrition and extending through complications of prematurity, recurrent pediatric illnesses, and multisystem comorbidities encompassing neurological, respiratory, dermatological, and psychosocial domains. Our analysis revealed a fundamental tension between the formal structure of biomedical data and the contingent realities embedded in patient narratives. This tension manifests in two interrelated challenges.
First being, dynamic data heterogeneity (unlike structured precision of biomedical data) that poses a persistent obstacle to context-sensitive decision-making.
Second, effective contextual reasoning for decision making demanding a shift from episodic, event-driven HIS logic to temporally fluid, flow-oriented digital data models.
[17/11, 16:45]pm: Questions around 18F from her current captured and archived data here:
And thematically analysed here:
Case 2: 18F Lifelong Flow
Temporal Depth
The second case traces the longitudinal health journey of an 18-year-old patient. The PaJR record demonstrated its ability to retain high-resolution historical data spanning 18 years without loss of contextual linkages, aggregating antenatal, neonatal (e.g., IVH, prematurity), childhood (recurrent RTIs, asthma), and adolescent data (nutrition, psychiatric consultation, dermatologic episodes).
Cross-Specialty Meshwork
In this case, decision-making emerged as a cross-specialty meshwork, facilitated by the PaJR platform's ability to host asynchronous and iterative contributions.
Rather than relying on sequential, isolated specialist encounters, the care team collaboratively built a shared plan: Pulmonology initiated an in-thread debate on the effectiveness of Pulmonary Function Testing (PFT) versus impulse oscillometer for optimizing asthma control; Psychiatry contributed essential context by assessing anxiety and stress triggers linked to the patient's physical dermatologic flares; Dermatology utilized this information to hypothesize environmental or nail-polish allergen sensitivity; and Nutrition logged daily dietary intake via PaJR to systematically track potential allergen exposure. This collective, non-linear contribution of diverse expertise to a unified patient journey demonstrates PaJR's capability as a flow integrator.
Environmental Trigger Mapping as Outcome
Daily PaJR logging by patient revealed a temporal association between nail polish application and onset of exfoliation. The outcome included a trailed allergen avoidance, adjusted inhaler regimen, and a structured stress-reduction plan.
[17/11, 16:50]pm: ๐ agree largely with @PPM3's inputs that our local synchronous face to face engagement with the patient using deeper history taking techniques helped us to deep dive into the patient's problems and this may have had some effect on shared decision making outcomes in terms of avoiding over-testing and overtreatment rather positively reinforcing healthy lifestyle choices.
However as per the problem statement and offered solution in the research question in the above paper draft what is the role of PaJR here?
[17/11, 18:46]pm: If the deadline is today better select two previously published PaJR cases that have already illustrated the advantages of actionable system 2 asynchronous cognition over system 1 expertise.
One recently by you and @PPM6 and team and another by @PPM8
[11.17 pm, 12/12/2025] PA: Today after returning back home from the college she suffers fever with 101.5 temp, body pain and cough n cold. She takes paracetamol 650 but she has to attend a workshop for next 2 days .pl guide her what to do...
[3.47 am, 13/12/2025] PA: With severe body pain she is unable to sleep at all and has a temp of 101.5 F
[7.19 am, 12/12/2025] PA: Temp --102.8F...
[7.23 am, 13/12/2025] PA: Continue to monitor temperature four hourly along with the pulse rate and BP and keep sharing here. Also can take Paracetamol 650 every six hours
[7.49 am, 13/12/2025] PA: After giving the icepack the temperature has reduced little. It is now 101.6F. Cough and cold has been there for a few days. There is severe pain in legs, head and back..
Sweating starts.... temperature is now 100.4F
Slightly feeling better. BP is 114/63, 129
[12.00 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: BP 121/61, 133. Temp. 100.4F
[4.22 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: BP 102/71, 128. Temp 100.8F
[4:39 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: In the afternoon suddenly, the patient starts shivering and palms, the soles of her feet become cold. She slightly feels chest and back pain. Immediately after soaking foot in warm water and applying hot water bag on the chest and back, it gets relief.
[4:43 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: Patient advocate feels that due to cough and cold she feels chest and back pain.
[7.50 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: Temp 100.6F. At 8.37 pm Temp 101.8F. BP 100/41, 155
[9.31 pm, 13/12/2025] PA: 103.6F
Ki korbo? Tmi jmn medicine diyecho tmn cholche.. paracetamol 3 times dilam
[7:56 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: How is she feeling subjectively at present?
[7:59 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: @PPM9 @RS2 can you check if the temperature readings available here are 4 hourly and if yes can you prepare a temperature chart for this patient similar to here ๐
[8:02 am, 14/12/2025] PA: From yesterday she checked her temparature ,BP nd pulse rate.also shared this group
[8:06 am, 14/12/2025] PA: Now her temperature is above 103 F. There is severe pain in back, head, leg and shoulder.15 mints after taking paracetamol starts sweating
[9:30 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Thanks. Do also keep sharing her BP and pulse along with the temperature readings so that we know when to approach your local doctor again for admission which would be a rare event in what we currently suspect to be a viral fever
[9:31 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Yes @RS2 @PPM9 please share those four values here again with time and temperature and pulse so that @PPM10 can ask his LLM to create a graph
[10:02 am, 14/12/2025] PA: After cold water compresses on head nd deep sleep for 1hour her temparature is 100F , BP is 80/41. pulse rate 134..
[10:04 am, 14/12/2025] PA: She doesn't want to take any solid food, want to take ors ,dark chocolate etc pl tell her what to do?
[10:19 am, 14/12/2025] PA: Takes 1 cup of ors
[10:55 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 10: Here are the extracted values from the image with available details:
- *Time*: 53 minutes ago (relative to time of reading)
- *Temperature*: Not displayed in the image
- *SYS (Systolic)*:
- kPa: Not fully visible in the image (partially cut off)
- mmHg: Not fully visible in the image (partially cut off)
- *DIA (Diastolic)*:
- kPa: Not fully visible in the image (partially cut off)
- mmHg: Not fully visible in the image (partially cut off)
- *Pulse (Pul/min)*: Value not fully visible in the image
The image shows the interface of a Dr. Moupper blood pressure monitor, but the numerical readings for SYS, DIA, and Pulse are cut off and not fully visible. Please reshare a clearer image or type out the four values (SYS in mmHg, DIA in mmHg, Pulse, and Time) along with temperature if available.
[10:56 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 10: Here are the updated vital signs after cold water compresses and 1 hour of deep sleep, formatted clearly for tracking and analysis:
---
*Time*: After 1-hour sleep + cold compress
*Temperature*: 100°F
*Blood Pressure*: 80/41 mmHg
*Pulse Rate*: 134 bpm
---
*Summary*:
- *BP*: 80/41 mmHg (low diastolic — stage 1 hypotension)
- *Pulse*: 134 bpm (tachycardia)
- *Temperature*: 100°F (mild fever)
Let me know if you'd like this formatted into a table for PPM10's LLM or if you'd like to add previous readings for trend analysis.
[11:14 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Can allow what she feels good to eat
[11:15 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Check her BP more frequently
[11:22 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: These are the temperature reading since Friday @PPM10
[12/12, 23:17] 101.2F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: Today after returning back home from the college she suffers fever with body pain and cough n cold. She takes paracetamol 650 but she has to attend a workshop for next 2 days .pl guide her what to do...
[13/12, 03:47] 101.1F
Patient Advocate 18F 44F Anthropology: Severe body pain all over the body, she is unable to sleep at all and lots of heat is coming out..
[13/12, 07:19] 102.8F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: Temp --102.8F...
[13/12, 07:59] 101.6F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: After giving the icepack the temperature has reduced little.It is now 101.6F. Cough and cold has been there for a few days. There is severe pain in legs, head and back..
[13/12, 09:29] 100.4F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: Sweating starts.... temperature is now 100.4F
[13/12, 12:15] 100.4F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: 100.4F
[13/12, 16:31] 100.8F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: 100.8F
[14/12, 08:06] 103 F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: Now her temparature is above 103 F.There is severe pain in back, head, leg and shoulder.15 mins after taking paracetamol starts sweating
[14/12, 10:02] 100F
Patient Advocate Diabetes 75F WB: After cold water compresses on head nd deep sleep for 1hour her temparature is 100F, BP is 80/41. pulse rate 134.
[11:26 am, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: A cleaner version of the temperature readings since Friday @PPM10 for your LLM to plot but please take care to keep it periodic at four hourly and not insert made up values to fill the gaps but leave those uncollected areas gaping
[12/12, 23:17] 101.2F
[13/12, 03:47] 101.1F
[13/12, 07:19] 102.8F
[13/12, 07:59] 101.6F
[13/12, 09:29] 100.4F
[13/12, 12:15] 100.4F
[13/12, 16:31] 100.8F
[14/12, 08:06] 103 F
[14/12, 10:02] 100F
[12.50 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: BP 106/46, 138. Lunch
[1:33 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Temperature?
[1:34 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Pulse pressure is 60? @PPM9?
[1:38 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Temperature is 101.8F at 1.35 pm
[1:40 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Yes sir
[1:42 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Why do you think it's high?
[1:42 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Generally it would give a water hammer pulse like sensation?
[1:44 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Sir due to very low diastolic blood pressure
[1:47 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: No sir it wouldn't because even though the diastolic bp has fallen but so has the systolic BP
[1:51 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Water hammer pulse is objectively characterized by a pulse pressure of 60 which is why in the final MBBS practical exams students would confirm by checking blood pressure before committing that the patient has a water hammer pulse
[1:52 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Yes what hemodynamic explains the high pulse pressure here is the question. Even if the systolic is low the pulse pressure is high at 60?
[1:53 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: But sir isn't it due to high systolic upstroke followed by diastolic collapse?
[1:54 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Sir given the pressures are both reduced yet the pulse rate is high
[1:54 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Hypovolemic?
[1:54 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Hypovolemia*
[1:54 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: And wouldn't that be reflected in the pulse pressure?
[1:55 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: We're focusing on the pulse pressure here
[1:55 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Yes sir objectively it should
[1:56 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: MBBS short note ๐
[2:00 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 11: Sir can it not be due to severe anaemia?
[2:03 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Sir Fever
[2:04 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9:?
[2.23 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: BP 90/29, 153.
[2.53 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Temperature reading?
[3:01 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: 101.8F
[3:02 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Is it monitor related issues?
[3:03 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: @PPM9 can you list all her pulse rates as shown in the images with her temperature readings confirming if they were taken at the same time?
Have you heard of relative bradycardia? @Meta AI is there anything similarly called relative tachycardia?
[3:03 pm, 14/12/2025] Meta AI: To answer your question accurately, I would need access to the specific images or data you're referring to, which I currently don't have. Could you please provide more context or share the images?
Regarding your second question, yes, "relative bradycardia" is a term used to describe a heart rate that is slower than expected given the clinical context, such as in a patient with fever or shock.
As for "relative tachycardia," it's not a commonly used term in the same context, but it could be used informally to describe a heart rate that's faster than expected for the patient's condition. Typically, you'd see terms like "tachycardia" or "inappropriate tachycardia" used instead.
[3:03 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: BP monitor? What issues?
[3:04 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Yes ,I doubt BP monitor Machine is properly working?
[3:04 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Why do you doubt the machine?
[3:05 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: She is feeling better than yesterday
[3:06 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: 90/29 is right or not?
[3:06 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: One way to check would be to manually count her pulse rate. For example when the monitor showed pulse rate as 153 per minute at 2:23 PM it would have be nice to have had it confirmed manually
[3:06 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: So down..
[3:16 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Check her pulse rate now. And let us know. After that immediately check her BP and let us know
[3.20 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: BP 77/29, 148
[3:23 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Better take her to her local doctor who saw her yesterday and get her monitored there
[3:23 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Could someone measure the pulse manually before taking this?
[3:26 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: 70
[3:29 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Manually check her pulse, it is 70/mint
[3:54 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Better take her to a nearby clinic and get her BP and pulse checked asap
[4.48 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Banana, nuts smoothies.
[4.57 pm, 14/12/205] PA: BP 78/33, 130
[5.11 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 12: Diastolic 33? Is that a verified machine?
[5.30 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: Temp 100.2F
[6:07 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1 Please take her to the local clinic or hospital to verify the readings and provide supportive therapy if when necessary
[6:08 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: Check others BP with the machine and let us know but please verify these with the local hospital support
[7:45 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: 110/60
[7:45 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: 70 pulse rate
[7:51 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Same time home instrument. BP 80/28, 149
[7:52 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Others instrument BP is 110/60, pulse 70
[8.02 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Boiled tomato and vegetables juice. Not taking solid food.
[8:14 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: Sir for today it was 138 pulse at 101.8F(same time)
153 pulse at 101.8F (almost 30 minutes difference in the time of taking pulse and temperature)
Let me know if you need past readings
[8:18 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: What would be the expected pulse rate for a 101F temperature? @Meta AI
[8:18 pm, 14/12/2025] Meta AI: For a temperature of 101.8°F, a typical increase in pulse rate would be around 10-15 beats per minute (bpm) above the normal range (usually 60-100 bpm for adults).
Given your temperature, an expected pulse rate could be roughly 70-115 bpm, considering the general guideline of an approximately 10 bpm increase per 1°F rise in temperature.
Your readings:
- 138 pulse at 101.8°F (same time): This seems within the expected range.
- 153 pulse at 101.8°F (30 minutes difference): This is a bit higher than expected but could be influenced by various factors like activity level, anxiety, or other medical conditions.
Do you want to share more readings or context?
[8:20 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 1: @Meta AI have you heard of relative bradycardia?
If the temperature is 101 and pulse rate is 110 per minute would that be expected?
If the temperature is 101 and the pulse rate is 70 per minute would that be expected or labeled as relative bradycardia?
[8:20 pm, 14/12/2025] Meta AI: Relative bradycardia is a heart rate that's lower than expected given the clinical context.
- Temperature 101°F and pulse rate 110 bpm: Yeah, that seems about right. For a 101°F temp, you'd expect a pulse increase of around 10-15 bpm, so 70-100 bpm + 10-15 bpm = 80-115 bpm. 110 bpm fits in that range.
- Temperature 101°F and pulse rate 70 bpm: This could be considered relative bradycardia. Typically, you'd expect the pulse to be higher with that temp.
In simple terms, relative bradycardia is when your body doesn't increase heart rate as much as expected with fever or other conditions.
[8:41 pm, 14/12/2025] PPM 9: @Meta AI reason?
[8:41 pm, 14/12/2025] Meta AI: Relative bradycardia can occur due to various reasons, including:
- Certain infections like typhoid fever, Legionnaires' disease, or psittacosis
- Medications like beta-blockers that slow heart rate
- Increased parasympathetic tone
- Cardiac conduction abnormalities
- Some autoimmune conditions
In some cases, it's also seen in athletes or individuals with high physical fitness, as their hearts are more efficient.
In your case, if the pulse rate is 70 bpm with a 101°F temp, it might be worth exploring potential underlying causes or discussing with a healthcare professional.
[8.58 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: Temp 102.6F.
[10.00 pm, 14/12/2025] PA2: Temp 102.6F
[10:56 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: In right hand BP 80/40
[10:57 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: In left hand 90/40
[11:01 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: At present Home monitor BP is 98/38, pulse 149.
[11:02 pm, 14/12/2025] PA: Manually pulse rate approx 105/mint
[7.31 am, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Please get her complete hemogram today with Hb, CBC and platelets including peripheral smear.
[7.59 am, 15/12/2025] PA2: Temp 101F
[10.51 am, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: She needs iv fluids and monitoring in a safe hospital setting.
[10.53 am, 15/12/2025] PA: BP 115/59, 124. Temp 101.4F. Patient had black tea.
[12.53 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: 115/59, 124
[2.23 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: BP 106/66, 107. Temp 99.8F
[4.27 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: I guess many of the PaJR team members here were on the edge of their seats yesterday while watching her BP fall along with her fever climb?
I talked to the patient advocate about it today and she said they don't have a proper hospital to take to and preferred our information support than going to the chaotic local hospital!
This is an important issue that needs to be addressed @PPM13@PPM14 @PPM9 @PPM11 @33FPA @PPM2 perhaps in another paper similar to the one that was published last week here: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12688023/
[4:29 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Kal ratri apnake bolechilam r ajker paper e berieche.
[4:29 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Apnader constant guidance r samanno jototuku monitoring o support e improvement hoyeche sure hospital e admit korle er theke kharap chara kichu hoto na ,r ei thanday bed o petona plane floor r rekhe dito,charpaser kukur r beral r majhe.
[4:30 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: ๐@RS2 I guess we don't have the four hourly values to plot this patient's fever chart?
[4:37 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: She wishes to take tea with salted something..
[4:39 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: For relief from constant cough she takes a small piece of ginger and honey
[4:56 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Now her pulse rate is increasing
[4:57 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Breathing in is so fast.
[5:05 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Take her to your local doctor and ask him to evaluate and text.
Share the morning blood reports
[5:06 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Temperature? Also manual count of the pulse rate?
Please check if your manual pulse rate checking is being done correctly through this video here ๐
[5:27 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: 1st time crosses her temparature above 104.4F
[5:28 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Heart rate approx 45 manually.
[5:29 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Not getting in the morning blood test report.
[5:46 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Going to nursing home..
[7:08 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Admission time O2, 94/93, pulse 144
[7:10 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: Let's hope for the best
[7:37 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Fever. 101F
[8:09 pm, 15/12/2025] PPM 1: At what time did she take her Paracetamol tablets today till now?
[9:31 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: She took paracetamol at 5 pm
[9:35 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: ECG done, Dr.said that ECG report almost normal just only high heart rate. It may be heavy dehydration, last BP was 90/50
[9:37 pm, 15/12/2025] PA: Morning blood test report.
[15/12, 21:59] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Admit kora hoye geche.group e post korechi blood report.Hb kom dekhlam...dr .bolchen viral fever mone hoche ..Dr.aj rate round d jaben terpor phone kore janaben .Amder khub porichito dr..amr ekber o mathay aseni ..onar under i admit kora hoyeche .
[15/12, 22:03] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Dr...xyz clinic ..janen bollen prochondo dehydration theke emn pulse naki bere jay..ki jani esob kichu bujhina ,apnarai janen...
[15/12, 22:08] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Tobe amr ekta bhoy lagche jokhon meyer BP drop korchilo r pulse bere gechilo kmn gol gol kore dekhchilo r kopal r thont finger tips bluish lagchilo .kmn ekta speed e kotha bolte chaichilo ..satty ki heart r somossa?bes kichudin dhorei khashi hochilo ,chest o pithe byatha bolchilo odbhut typer kashir sound ...tb type kichu hoynito?
[15/12, 23:15] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ei just Dr. sathe kotha hoyeche Maleria,dengue payni.liver ektu somossa ache lipase kichuta high ..r Kashi ta khub hoche.
[15/12, 23:15] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Lungs e halka pnwumonia
[15/12, 23:15] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Dr.pathalen
[15/12, 23:57] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Jondice o payni
[16/12, 06:52] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Pneumonia thik hoye jabeto?
[16/12, 07:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Rate 102 Tempareture chilo,nebulizer diyeche ..ekhon abr jor eseche 100.4F. Paser bedr jnno fan chalate hoyechilo tai meyer naki meyer gaye fan r haoa lagchilo ..kan e byatha korche..
[16/12, 07:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj whole abdomen USG hobe.
[16/12, 07:58]pm: Chest X-ray?
[16/12, 08:00] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Admit korar somoy dr.bolechilen chest x_ray korbe ..Kal round e ese amy call kore bollen .Details kichui janina .
[16/12, 08:01] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ekhon nurshi g home call kore jante chailam kmn ache ?rate ghumie chilo kina?tokhon jante perlam ..
[16/12, 07:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Rate 102 Tempareture chilo,nebulizer diyeche ..ekhon abr jor eseche 100.4F. Paser bedr jnno fan chalate hoyechilo tai meyer naki meyer gaye fan r haoa lagchilo ..kan e byatha korche..
[16/12, 07:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj whole abdomen USG hobe.
[16/12, 07:58]pm: Chest X-ray?
[16/12, 08:00] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Admit korar somoy dr.bolechilen chest x_ray korbe ..Kal round e ese amy call kore bollen .Details kichui janina .
[16/12, 08:01] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ekhon nurshi g home call kore jante chailam kmn ache?rate ghumie chilo kina?tokhon jante perlam ..
[3.36 pm, 16/12/2025] PPM 1: Please share all the temperature readings four hourly.
[3:38 pm, 16/12/2025] PPM 1: This is our current hospital patient's handwritten fever chart
[5:23 pm, 16/12/2025] PPM 12: Curious on the color (pallor - mild, moderate, severe) on her cheeks, nail bed, tongue?
Jor kome geche?
[16/12, 21:25]: Respiratory rate?
[16/12, 21:39] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Nursing home theke pelam na fever chart.dupure 100.2f chilo.saradin 3 ber jor eseche eituku dr. Bollen.samanno xray plate dekhte gelam tai hat dite dilona .
[16/12, 21:40] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Kono monitor nei, respiratory rate jigasa korechilam bolo thik ache. kal theke
[16/12, 21:42] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ent dekhe gechen ektu age bolechen lungs theke infection kan porjonto spread kore geche 2-3din time lagbe..ektu age nursing home meyer sathe kotha bollam
[8.16 am, 17/12/2025] PA: As per nursing home information, The patient's saline has been withdrawn, she takes food orally as per taste. A CT scan has been advised and referred to Pulmonologist. Pulse rate is above 125. Fever 100.4F (this morning). She is gasping for breath while talking.
[8:51 am, 17/12/2025] PPM 1: Yes hence knowing the hourly respiratory rate was important other than the four hourly fever charting
[8:53 am, 17/12/2025] PPM 1: @PPM15 can you talk to the doctor of this nursing home from your town if he can share with us the vitals chart since admission?
Looks like she has pulmonary edema due to a viral pneumonia similar to covid and may even require ventilation
Her treating team would need to know her regular SpO2, FiO2, among other vitals to decide on ventilation if when necessary.
He has started on meropenem and doxycycline
Tomorrow they will send pleural fluid for analysis
[7:57 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: She might need a gram positive coverage too?
[8:07 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 1: Can we have the record of her vitals since admission?
[8:14 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: It's unlikely for the nursing home to share documents Sir
[8:15 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: But her pneumonia doesn't look good on CT
[8:16 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: If paO2 is not available, SpO2 needs to be checked once
[8:55 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 1: "Patients or their respective caretakers have the right to access the originals or copies of case papers, indoor patient records and investigation reports. Investigation reports have to be made available to them within 24 hours of admission"
[9:27 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: Yes but the problem is if the healthcare facility doesn't provide the document, the onus is on the patient to get a court order for the documents and then also each party can pursue upto the division bench of the Supreme Court, thereby wasting years and lakhs of rupees in the process. A better way might be to ask the treating doctor to share it verbally/unofficially.
[9:43 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 1: @PPM15 has spoken to him
[9:53 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 16: That's great
[10:07 pm, 17/12/2025] PPM 15: I will try to ask him but getting in patient documents maybe difficult since healthcare facilities dont provide them
[8:19 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: Exactly that's the question our current paper on "Resolving diagnostic and therapeutic uncertainty aka clinical complexity..." is trying to ask? @PPM16 @PPM2 @PPM9 @PPM17 @42MPA
Why are we as physicians scared to be transparent and accountable as long as we are sure we are doing the right thing?
Doesn't hiding data add to existing diagnostic and therapeutic knowledge gaps aka epistemic uncertainty and makes it considerably difficult to interpret existing information aka hermeneutic uncertainty as per this paper earlier shared by @PPM13 ๐
[8:34 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 16: Because most treatment done in remote/rural facilities of developing (even developed) nations can't be as per clinical practice guidelines framed in ivory towers of central academic institutions, and doctors are legitimately scared of being pulled up by regulators for not following guidelines, when most of the tests/treatment recommended by these guidelines might not be available in a small nursing home operating in a remote area
[8:40 am, 18/12/2025] PA: It will be very important and effective for us.
[8:47 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: Hence the need to understand real world complexity at a ground level where current guidelines can't penetrate (epistemic uncertainty) leaving lot of scope to reformulate them as per low resource requirements?
[9:19 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 16: Of course. But how to do it?
[10:24 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: The first step is data gathering at the ground level while accepting that it will be thwarted by current barriers such as habitual lack of transparency and accountability as in this particular case scenario as among many but if people like @PPM15 can help us to navigate this on ground then we can make tremendous progress.
[11.00 am, 18/12/2025] PPM 16: The first step in data gathering will be building trust with the primary care physician, so that he/she can recognise the global network as a peer support system rather than a threat.
[12:32 pm, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: Hence we have roped in @PPM15 for this particular patient who fortuitously happens to be from that location
[12:47 pm, 18/12/2025] PPM 2: I think on this one, the bark is stronger than the bite. As long as two consenting parties agree to a specific treatment pathway and this is clearly documented, no regulatory authority can supervene.
The regulatory overreach is a bit overstated.
[4:42 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: Sir, how many days she has to stay in hospital?
[4:45 pm, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: We currently don't have the data to predict that
We need to see her daily vitals chart to be able to speculate about it. Currently most of what is happening to her is opaque to us.
[4:51 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: Now her pulse is 88
[9:48 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: Throughout the day the patient's body temperature remained within 100F, oxygen was 93_94, pulse rate was 80-88 but the patient advocate is very sorry, she was not able to collect 4 hourly chart.
[9:49 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: Sputum test done.
[9:50 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: She has severe back pain, hot water bag gives relief
[9:52 pm, 18/12/2025] PPM 1: Was the pleural tap done?
[9:53 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: No.
[9:54 pm, 18/12/2025] PA: Doctor wanted to wait for today.
[8:22 am, 19/12/2025] PA: Can the pain be reduced by doing a pleural tap? Is there any risk as per Xray or CT scan report?
[8:51 am, 19/12/2025] PPM 1: Dyadic conversational update for PaJR team based learning around current healthcare systems communications optimization requirements: @PPM6 @PPM10 @PPM12 @PPM2 @PPM18 @PPM3
[18/12, 22:05] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj vison hectic geche ,sokale dr.bollen aj wait dekhben medicine e kotota plural water reduce hoche then tomorrow bhaben .
[18/12, 22:06] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj hemi thorax (CT thorax?) hoyeche kintu sandhey bela porjonto report aseni .janina ki ache.
[18/12, 22:07] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: govt.hospital theke sputum test korar kotha bolechilen dr.
[18/12, 22:16] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Parallelly nursing home nijeo korte diyeche .ami hospital theke container jokhon nite gelam kichutei dilona nursing home patient bole ,ulte Amy bollo 2 taka diye outdoor tckt kore patient dekhie admit korun terpor test hobe.
etotai misbehave koreche then Abr dr. k call kori , nursing home jai,kotha boli X_ray o scan plate niye abr government hospital jai terpor o dite chayna .ward jai then tarao deny kore ..abr nursing home jai ,okhan theke Super sathe kotha bole,abr back to hospital tao deyna ...vison jed chepe gechilo lastly dots department e giye dekha kori tokhon sob paper dekhe container dey clearly bolen aei government hospital r machine kharap, test hobena.
ora baire pathabe minimum 7days lagbe report pete.
[18/12, 22:17] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ei report jonno jno dr.wait na koren ,dr.j o ninermotoi treatment korte thake .
[18/12, 22:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Lastly puro case history nebr por bole arekta govt hospital theke jno ei sputum test korai..
[18/12, 22:18] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Janina kal ki hoyrani opekshay korche arekta govt hospital e r ter report I. Ki asbe?
[18/12, 22:20] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Bujhte perchena sir samanno ekta container niye ki hoyrani hote hoyeche.. hospital office bose table banie kotha boleche even RMO dr.k niye bolen amr Enadr chinina ...
[18/12, 22:22] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Saradin eto dourate giye ek somoy nijer mone hochilo buk mone hoy fete jache ,sarir kapche ..ek do o
[18/12, 22:22] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ekhon ekdom r chap nite parin
[18/12, 22:22] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Khub kosto hochilo
[18/12, 22:27] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj Local PaJR dr. call korechilen Amy sobta sunlen r bollen porsudin personally nursing home r sathe kotha bolben
[18/12, 22:28] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Ei matro nursing home phone korechilam ,sunlam abr kichu blood test r urine test korte diyechen ...kintu chest er byapare kichu boleni j kal drain out korben kina?
[18/12, 22:29] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Nebulizer cholche ekhon tai meyer sathe kotha bola gelona
[18/12, 22:30] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Amr kno janina unnecessary kichu test hoche
[18/12, 22:54] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Local PaJR Dr. bollen ashakora jache natun antibiotic Meropenem kaj korche..time lagbe recovery hote
[19/12, 07:11] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Aj visiting hours e Dr. r sathe ki kotha bolbo ba jigasa bole din na....
[19/12, 07:56]pm: Ore chest theke olpo fluid ki testing er jonye bar kora hoyeche?
[19/12, 08:13] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Na na kal obdhi kichu koreni ,aj bolechen korbe?ami totally confused 1st day thekei jokhon bojha jache pneumonia ache tahole kno kono dr.bollen na?ami nije ber ber ei bhoy tai peyechilam ,sadharon manush hisebe nije feel korchi tahole kno erokom korchen dr. bujhe perchina .. nursing home e admit hober 2 din r modhey clear hoye geche pneumonia develop koreche ,patch ache, fluid ache tahole kno onara tap korchena?meye ta kaal vison kosto peyeche ,back hoche constant ...apni bolun na aj ki bolbo dr. k?
[19/12, 08:14] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: RMO bolechen aj fluid collect kore test pathabe but tap kore ber korben seta kintu jigasa koray bollen na..
[19/12, 08:39]pm: Test kore pathalei jotheshto. Tap kore bar kora dorkar nao hote pare.
Amader fluid ta test kore eta jana dorkar je ota transudative na exudative ebong otar cell count koto ebong parle fluid er CBNAAT tao pathano dorkar jetar jonye apni goto kal government hospital a ghurechen.
Unara hoito government hospital shei test ta nebe kina confirm korar jonyei fluid ta testing er jonye pathate somoi nicchilen ebong patient er condition er aro tottho jeguno amra jehetu patient ke continuously dekhte parchina aerokom thakte pare jar jonye tap kore uthte parenni.
[9:04 am, 19/12/2025] PPM 1: [19/12, 08:42] Patient Advocate Diabetes 18F WB: Tahole aj ki jigasa korbo dr.k?
[19/12, 09:03]pm: Ora jebhabe kaaj korche korte din.
Apatoto asha korchi unnotir pothe ache jodio detailed hourly information er obhabe kichu amader torof theke immediately suggest kora kothin.
Oi dhoroner clinical information jeta amra roj amader nijer hospital patient der theke pete obhyosto, jemon hourly chart jeta gotokal share korechilam, sheguno daktar ke just jiggesh kore jana sombhob noi, tabe aaste aaste olpo sholpo doinondin information theke joto tuku janaa jai toto ta jene joto ta anuman kora jai tai kora jak.
[9:23 am, 19/12/2025] PA: When the patient talks to her. mother and other family members from the nursing home, she feels quite better. Back pain is there, hot water bag continues, now she has no fever.
No comments:
Post a Comment