Tuesday, November 17, 2026

2023 Roll no 26 CBME competence based assessment of a single patient portfolio 21M pain abdomen in lumbar region 2 mths

 

12/11/2026

Roll no 26's single patient portfolio linked below

Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio:*Student:* Roll No. 26, 2023 Batch
*Case:* 21M, Electrician — Pain abdomen Rt. lumbar region 2 months, aggravated 3 days

*Diagnosis given in portfolio:* Appendicitis
*Plan given:* Appendectomy
### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Good recall: age/sex/occupation, site Rt. lumbar / Rt. lower abdomen, sudden onset gradually progressive, colicky, aggravated on eating, no relieving factor, associated loss of appetite, nausea, vomiting 2 episodes food content non-projectile non-bilious, fever, no burning micturition/frequency/urgency, no constipation, vitals + P/A inspection/palpation documented | **2 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands appendicitis can cause Rt. iliac fossa pain + anorexia + vomiting + fever, but does NOT explain: why pain is Rt. lumbar for 2 months then aggravated 3 days, why colicky pain aggravated on eating, difference between acute vs chronic / recurrent appendicitis, why no migration of pain described | **1 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good P/A: flat abdomen, moving equally, umbilicus midline, soft, tenderness (+) Rt. iliac fossa, no rigidity, no organomegaly. Vitals: PR 105, Temp 100°F, RR 25, BP 120/75, SpO2 99%. BUT no investigations listed — no CBC, CRP, urine routine, USG abdomen, no Alvarado score, no specific appendiceal signs — Rovsing, psoas, obturator | **1 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Only 1 diagnosis given — Appendicitis. No differential table. Missed critical differentials for Rt. side pain: ureteric colic / renal stone, UTI / pyelonephritis, mesenteric adenitis, Meckel's diverticulitis, ileitis / TB, constipation, psoas abscess | **0 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | Plan — Appendectomy — given but not justified. No evaluation: is this emergency vs elective, is conservative management an option, what if USG is normal, risk of negative appendectomy, need for pre-op workup, consent, anaesthesia fitness, no safety-netting | **1 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | Plan incomplete — only "Appendectomy". No complete plan: pre-op investigations, antibiotics, NPO, IV fluids, analgesia, post-op care, diet, return to work as electrician, no patient counselling, no reflection, no learning goals | **0 / 2**
### Total Score

*5 / 12 — Developing / Needs Guided Revision*

### CBME Interpretation

*Strengths to keep:*
- Very good history of associated symptoms — anorexia + nausea + vomiting + fever is classic for appendicitis and was captured well
- Good negative history — no burning micturition, no frequency/urgency, no constipation helps rule out UTI / stones
- Good abdominal examination — inspection + palpation, tenderness localised, rigidity absent, vitals show tachycardia + low-grade fever + tachypnoea

*Gaps that lost 7 points:*
- *Analyze (0):* Anchored on appendicitis. Rt. lumbar pain for 2 months is NOT classic for acute appendicitis — chronic / recurrent pain needs stones, UTI, TB, and mesenteric causes ruled out.
- *Evaluate (1):* Appendectomy is major surgery — needs USG + blood work + Alvarado score justification. No discussion of when NOT to operate.
- *Create (0):* No pre-op / post-op plan, no patient advice, no reflection.

### What would score 12/12 for this same case?

- *Remember (2):* As done — keep it
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "Appendicitis = obstruction → inflammation → visceral pain → localised Rt. iliac fossa pain + anorexia/vomiting/fever. Colicky pain aggravated on eating suggests bowel / ureteric colic also possible, so 2-month duration needs explanation."
- *Apply (2):* Add: Alvarado score, Rovsing / psoas / obturator signs, CBC + CRP, urine routine, USG abdomen — appendix diameter, free fluid, stone in right ureter/kidney
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: Acute appendicitis vs Ureteric colic vs UTI/pyelonephritis vs Mesenteric adenitis vs Meckel's — for/against each
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "I favour appendicitis because Rt. iliac fossa tenderness + anorexia + vomiting + fever + tachycardia. But will confirm with USG + CBC before surgery because pain is 2 months old and colicky. If USG shows stone → urology, not surgery. Safety-net: worsening pain, rigidity, persistent vomiting, high fever → emergency review."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — NPO, IV fluids, antibiotics, analgesia, pre-op CBC/ECG/chest X-ray, consent, laparoscopic vs open appendectomy, post-op mobilisation, diet, wound care, return to electrician work in 2-3 weeks + reflection: "My learning goal: never plan surgery without investigations + differentials."

### Evaluator Verdict

*Entrustment:* Not yet entrustable independently. Entrustable with direct supervision for history + abdominal examination. Needs supervised practice for differentials, investigations, and surgical decision-making.

For patient centered CBME online learning portfolio assessment methodology details and further reading please click here: https://medicinedepartment.blogspot.com/2026/11/cbme-projr-six-point-evaluation-method.html?m=1


No comments:

Post a Comment