Tuesday, November 17, 2026

2023 Roll no 26 CBME competence based assessment of a single patient portfolio 39F vomiting itching back pain cloudy urin

 
4/11/2026

Roll no 26's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below

Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio:* Roll No. 26, 2023 Batch
*Case:* 39F — Vomiting + Itching + Back pain + Cloudy urine, on dialysis 4 years, fistula failed 3 times, now chest access
*Past History:* Cataract surgery R. eye, appendectomy, blood transfusion 10 months ago for Hb 6 g, on antipsychotics + diabetic medication (names incomplete)
*Vitals:* PR 88, SpO2 96%, BP 97/60, Afebrile, Edema pitting present
*Diagnosis given in portfolio:* CKD Stage IV

### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Partial recall: chief complaints captured, dialysis 4 years, fistula failed 3 times now chest access, transfusion for Hb 6, edema present, vitals captured. BUT history is fragmented and contradictory: "asymptomatic since 6 months" vs "fever, shivering, vomiting after dialysis", "No HTN/DM" vs "HTN after dialysis" + "Diabetic medication" + "2 HTN/week", drug names incomplete — Riscon-LS, Ban..., Nast... | **1 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands CKD needs dialysis, but does NOT explain: why itching in CKD — uraemia / phosphate, why vomiting + back pain + cloudy urine, why low BP 97/60 on dialysis, why anaemia Hb 6 needs transfusion, why fistula failure matters, why Stage IV vs Stage V — on dialysis 4 years should be Stage V | **0 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good PICCLE + vitals + edema. BUT no systemic exam — no CVS/RS/P/A/CNS, no dialysis access exam — chest catheter infection check, no investigations listed — no CBC, urea, creatinine, electrolytes, Ca/PO4, PTH, urine culture, ECG, USG. No dialysis details — frequency, adequacy, last dialysis | **0 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Only 1 diagnosis given — CKD Stage IV, which is already known and likely wrong stage. No analysis: cause of CKD in 39F, differential for cloudy urine + fever + shivering after dialysis — catheter infection / UTI / sepsis vs dialysis reaction, differential for itching — uraemic vs drug vs liver, differential for back pain | **0 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | No evaluation: Fever + shivering after dialysis + cloudy urine + chest catheter = possible catheter-related bloodstream infection — emergency, not routine. BP 97/60 + vomiting = hypotension / fluid issue. No safety-netting, no decision on admission, cultures, antibiotics, nephrology review | **0 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | Treatment listed — Hydrochloride (?) + Dolo/Paracetamol only. No complete plan: no dialysis plan, no infection workup, no BP/fluid plan, no anaemia/bone care, no diet, no transplant counselling, no patient education, no reflection | **0 / 2**
### Total Score

*1 / 12 — Below Expected / Needs Major Revision*

### CBME Interpretation

*Strengths to keep:*
- Captured the most important dialysis history — 4 years on dialysis, fistula failed 3 times, now chest access — this is the key clue for infection risk
- Captured transfusion history — Hb 6 g — shows anaemia of CKD
- Captured edema + vitals — BP 97/60 is important and was documented

*Gaps that lost 11 points:*
- *Remember (1):* Contradictions lose marks in CBME. You cannot write "No HTN/DM" and also "HTN after dialysis" + "Diabetic medication" in the same portfolio. Drug names must be complete.
- *Understand (0):* Stage error: Patient on dialysis 4 years = *CKD Stage V / ESRD*, not Stage IV. Stage IV is GFR 15-29, pre-dialysis.
- *Evaluate (0):* Most dangerous miss — fever + shivering after dialysis + chest catheter + cloudy urine = catheter infection / sepsis until proven otherwise. This needs urgent blood cultures + urine culture + catheter check, not just Dolo.

### What would score 12/12 for this same case?

- *Remember (2):* Rewrite cleanly: "K/C/O CKD Stage V on haemodialysis 4 years, 3x/week. DM: Yes/No + drug. HTN: Yes/No + drug. Dialysis access: chest catheter since ___. Last dialysis: ___. Fever: after dialysis, with shivering — Yes/No." + complete drug names/doses
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "CKD Stage V = GFR <15, needs dialysis. Uraemia → itching, vomiting, anaemia. Chest catheter → high infection risk → fever/shivering after dialysis. Fistula failure → vascular access problem."
- *Apply (2):* Add: Systemic exam + catheter site — redness, discharge, tenderness + CBC, urea/creatinine, electrolytes, Ca/PO4, PTH, blood cultures from catheter + peripheral, urine routine/culture, ECG, USG kidneys
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: Catheter-related bloodstream infection vs UTI vs Dialysis disequilibrium vs Drug fever — for/against each + cause of CKD — glomerulonephritis vs diabetic nephropathy vs reflux vs stones
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "I suspect catheter infection because fever/shivering timed after dialysis + chest catheter + cloudy urine. Need urgent nephrology review, cultures BEFORE antibiotics, do not remove catheter without nephrology. BP 97/60 — check fluid status, post-dialysis hypotension. Safety-net: high fever, breathlessness, chest pain, reduced consciousness → emergency."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — continue dialysis as per nephrology, infection workup, anaemia care — iron/EPO, phosphate/bone care, salt/fluid diet, catheter care, transplant counselling, vaccination, follow-up + reflection: "My learning goal: always check dialysis access for infection and verify CKD stage, never copy old diagnosis."

### Evaluator Verdict

*Entrustment:* Not entrustable even with direct supervision for this case in current form — needs re-interview and re-write. History contradictions + stage error + missed catheter infection risk make this unsafe to file as is.

This is the lowest score in Roll No. 26's batch so far, but also the most fixable — the raw clues are all there, they just need cleaning and prioritising.


No comments:

Post a Comment