7/11/2026
Roll no 26's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below
Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio:* Roll No. 26, 2023 Batch
*Case:* 58F — Pain in back 4 days + Joints pain 4 days
*Vitals (Set 1):* BP 130/80, PR 88, RR 22, SpO2 97%, Temp 98.6°F
*Vitals (Set 2):* BP 110/70, PR 87, SpO2 100%, Temp 98.4°F, Pallor (+)
*Diagnoses given in portfolio:* 1) LBA (Low Back Ache) 2) Recurrent urinary tract infections
### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Partial recall: back pain insidious gradual progressive 4 days, joint pain 4 days, pain on sitting, no DM/HTN/Thyroid/Epilepsy/TB, good back exam — midline lumbar tenderness, paraspinal tenderness, left SI joint tenderness, raised local temp. BUT major inconsistency: 2 different vitals sets + 2 different provisional diagnoses in same portfolio, no urinary history at all — no burning, frequency, urgency, fever, cloudy urine — to support UTI, no joint exam — which joints, swelling, redness? | **1 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands LBA = back pain, but does NOT explain: why back pain + joint pain together, why raised local temp + midline tenderness matters, how UTI causes back pain — loin pain vs lumbar pain, why pallor (+) matters, why bowel/bladder irregular + disturbed sleep matters | **0 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good back inspection + palpation — best back exam in this batch. BUT no investigations listed — no X-ray/MRI lumbar spine, no CBC, ESR/CRP, urine routine/culture, RFT, calcium/vitamin D, no neuro exam — SLR, power, sensation, reflexes, no joint examination despite joint pain complaint | **1 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Two diagnoses listed — LBA + Recurrent UTI — but no analysis linking them. No differential table. Missed: Lumbar spondylosis vs Disc prolapse vs SI joint dysfunction vs Pyelonephritis / UTI vs Vertebral TB / Osteomyelitis vs Osteoporotic fracture vs Inflammatory arthritis | **0 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | No evaluation: Is this mechanical back pain or infective? Raised local temp + midline tenderness + pallor = red flag, needs urgent workup. No evaluation of which diagnosis is primary, no red-flag assessment — fever, weight loss, trauma, bladder/bowel involvement, weakness, no safety-netting | **0 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | No management plan. No plan for pain relief, physiotherapy, posture, investigations, UTI treatment, follow-up, no patient counselling for 58F, no reflection, no learning goals | **0 / 2**
### Total Score
*2 / 12 — Below Expected / Needs Major Revision*
### CBME Interpretation
*Strengths to keep:*
- Best musculoskeletal examination in Roll No. 26's batch so far — midline tenderness, paraspinal tenderness, left SI tenderness, raised local temp, posture/gait, pain on sitting — very well documented
- Good negative history — no DM/HTN/Thyroid/TB helps narrow causes
- Good systemic exam — CVS/RS/P/A/CNS done
*Gaps that lost 10 points:*
- *Remember (1):* This looks like *two cases mixed into one portfolio* — Set 1 vitals + LBA, Set 2 vitals + Pallor + Recurrent UTI. In CBME, one portfolio = one patient, one vitals set, one diagnosis. This needs splitting or correcting.
- *Analyze (0):* Back pain + joint pain + pallor + raised local temp in a 58F is NOT simple LBA. Could be inflammatory, infective, or anaemia-related — needs differentials.
- *Evaluate (0):* If UTI is truly present, where is the urinary history? If LBA is primary, why mention UTI? The examiner cannot tell which is the provisional diagnosis.
### What would score 12/12 for this same case?
- *Remember (2):* Fix to one patient, one vitals set. Add: Back pain — site, radiation to leg?, aggravating/relieving, morning stiffness? Joints — which joints, swelling, morning stiffness >30 min? Urinary — burning, frequency, urgency, fever, cloudy/foul urine, prior UTI episodes — how many in 1 year?
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "Mechanical LBA = pain on sitting/movement, no fever. Infective back pain / pyelonephritis = loin pain + fever + burning urine + raised temp. Inflammatory arthritis = joint pain + morning stiffness + back pain in older female."
- *Apply (2):* Add: Neuro exam — SLR, power, sensation, reflexes + CBC, ESR/CRP, urine routine/culture, RFT, X-ray lumbar spine, Vitamin D/calcium + joint exam
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: Lumbar spondylosis vs Disc prolapse vs SI dysfunction vs Pyelonephritis vs Vertebral TB — for/against each. Decide: Primary = ? Secondary = ?
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "Raised local temp + midline tenderness + pallor = cannot call simple LBA, need to rule out infection/TB. If urine shows pus cells + culture positive + fever/burning → UTI/pyelonephritis is primary, back pain is loin pain. If urine normal → mechanical/inflammatory back pain is primary. Safety-net: fever, weakness in legs, bladder/bowel loss, weight loss → emergency."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — analgesia, rest vs mobilisation, physiotherapy, posture, hydration, UTI antibiotics if proven, anaemia workup for pallor, follow-up with urine culture + X-ray + reflection: "My learning goal: never file two diagnoses + two vitals in one portfolio — clarify history first."
### Evaluator Verdict
*Entrustment:* Not entrustable even with direct supervision in current form — needs re-interview and re-write to clarify if this is LBA or UTI, and to resolve the two vitals sets.
The back examination itself is entrustable — keep that part exactly as is, just fix the rest around it.

No comments:
Post a Comment