2/11/2026
Roll no 26's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below
Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio: Roll No. 26, 2023 Batch
*Case:* 23F, Student — Swelling both lower limbs 5 years + Reduced urine output + Known kidney failure on regular hemodialysis
*Diagnosis given in portfolio:* CKD Stage V
*Investigations given:* CBC, Blood urea, S. Creatinine
### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Good recall: age/sex/occupation, swelling both LL 5 years mild → progressive, reduced urine, kidney function deteriorated → kidney failure, on scheduled hemodialysis, HTN 5 years, Saradon since 2 years, PICCLE (+) bilateral pedal pitting edema, vitals PR 88 regular, BP 180/100, SpO2 98%, systemic exam CVS/RS/P/A/CNS done | **2 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands CKD = progressive kidney failure → swelling + oliguria, but does NOT explain: why swelling in CKD, why HTN in CKD, why BP 180/100 is dangerous on dialysis day, what Stage V means — GFR <15, need for dialysis/transplant, why Saradon (paracetamol) is not HTN treatment | **1 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good general + systemic exam, pitting edema documented. Investigations started — CBC, urea, creatinine — but incomplete: no electrolytes, calcium/phosphate, bicarbonate, PTH, Hb, urine, ECG, USG kidneys, ABG. No dialysis details — frequency, AV fistula, weight, fluid intake | **1 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Only 1 diagnosis given — CKD Stage V, which is already known. No analysis of cause of CKD in 23F, no differential for swelling: CKD vs heart failure vs liver vs thyroid vs nephrotic. No analysis of why CKD at 23 — glomerulonephritis, reflux, stones, congenital, autoimmune? | **1 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | No evaluation of urgency: BP 180/100 + CKD Stage V + on dialysis = hypertensive emergency risk, needs immediate BP control, fluid assessment, ECG. No evaluation of dialysis adequacy, anaemia, bone disease, no safety-netting for breathlessness, chest pain, seizures, decreased consciousness | **0 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | No management plan. No plan for BP control, diet — salt/fluid/potassium/protein, dialysis compliance, transplant counselling, anaemia/bone care, vaccination, no patient counselling for a 23-year-old student, no reflection, no learning goals | **0 / 2**
### Total Score
*5 / 12 — Developing / Needs Guided Revision*
### CBME Interpretation
*Strengths to keep:*
- Clear chronological story — 5-year progression from swelling to kidney failure to dialysis, well captured
- Good examination — pitting nature of edema documented, not just "swelling"
- Correctly identifies CKD Stage V and lists core renal investigations
*Gaps that lost 7 points:*
- *Analyze (1):* This is a known case, so the task is not to diagnose CKD, but to analyse _why_ a 23F has CKD Stage V and _what complications_ she has now. That analysis is missing.
- *Evaluate (0):* BP 180/100 in CKD Stage V is the most urgent finding in this portfolio and is not addressed. Saradon for HTN is also not questioned — paracetamol does not control BP.
- *Create (0):* No holistic plan for a young student on lifelong dialysis — diet, mental health, education, transplant, family screening.
### What would score 12/12 for this same case?
- *Remember (2):* As done — keep it
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "CKD Stage V = GFR <15, kidneys cannot clear urea/creatinine/fluid → swelling, oliguria, HTN, anaemia. HTN both causes and worsens CKD. Dialysis replaces filtration but does not cure CKD."
- *Apply (2):* Add: Weight, fluid intake/output, AV fistula check, lung crepitations, JVP + CBC, urea/creatinine, Na/K, Ca/PO4, bicarbonate, PTH, Hb, ECG, USG kidneys — small echogenic kidneys, urine protein
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: Cause of CKD in young female — chronic glomerulonephritis vs reflux nephropathy vs polycystic vs lupus nephritis vs stones — plus complications: HTN, anaemia, mineral-bone disease, acidosis, hyperkalaemia
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "BP 180/100 on dialysis day is uncontrolled — risk of stroke, heart failure, pulmonary edema. Check if missed dialysis/meds, fluid overload, need urgent nephrology review. Saradon is analgesic, not antihypertensive — need proper antihypertensive review. Safety-net: breathlessness, chest pain, swelling worsening, very low urine, drowsiness → emergency."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — continue scheduled dialysis, salt/fluid restriction, low potassium diet, BP drugs per nephrology, anaemia + calcium/vitamin D care, transplant counselling, vaccination, mental health + studies support, follow-up with nephrology + reflection: "My learning goal: always assess BP + complications + cause in CKD, not just label Stage V."
### Evaluator Verdict
*Entrustment:* Not yet entrustable independently. Entrustable with direct supervision for history + edema examination in CKD. Needs supervised practice for cause analysis, emergency BP assessment, and holistic CKD management planning.

No comments:
Post a Comment