Tuesday, November 17, 2026

2023 Roll no 36 CBME competence based assessment of a single patient portfolio 42M SOB limb swelling 6 mths

 
11/11/2026

Roll no 36's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below

Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio:* Roll No. 36
*Case:* 42M, Farmer — Shortness of Breath 6 months + B/L limb swelling 6 months

*Past History:* K/C/O HTN 3 years, H/o pain in hypochondrium, Family H/o HTN mother + father, No DM/TB/Epilepsy
*Vitals:* BP 160/100, PR 88, RR 22, SpO2 94% RA, Temp 98.6°F
*Diagnosis given in portfolio:* CKD

### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Good recall: SOB gradual 6 months aggravated exertion + lying down relieved rest, swelling both LL gradual pitting ankle → up, aggravated prolonged standing relieved elevation, HTN 3 years, family HTN, appetite decreased, sleep disturbed, vitals captured, PICCLE negative, CVS/CNS/RS/P/A done. BUT contradictions: "Aggravated by lying down" + "No orthopnea, PND" — lying-down dyspnoea IS orthopnea, "No decreased urine output" listed twice but CKD claimed | **1 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands SOB + swelling + HTN can be CKD, but does NOT explain: why CKD causes SOB — fluid overload / anaemia / acidosis, why swelling in CKD, why BP 160/100 matters, why SpO2 94% + RR 22 matters, why no facial puffiness / abdominal distension was checked | **1 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good vitals + systemic exam. BUT no targeted exam: no JVP, no lung crepitations, no edema grading, no urine output measurement, no pallor/edema in PICCLE despite swelling complaint, no investigations listed — no CBC, urea, creatinine, electrolytes, urine, ECG, echo, chest X-ray, USG kidneys | **1 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Only 1 diagnosis given — CKD. No differential table. Missed critical differentials for SOB + swelling: Heart failure, CKD, Liver failure, Nephrotic syndrome, Anaemia, COPD, Cor pulmonale, DVT, Hypothyroidism. Pain in hypochondrium not analysed — liver congestion vs gastritis? | **0 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | No evaluation: Is this CKD or heart failure? BP 160/100 + SOB on lying down + swelling = heart failure must be ruled out first. No assessment of urgency — SpO2 94% + RR 22 + orthopnoea = needs urgent evaluation, no safety-netting for breathlessness at rest, chest pain, very low urine | **0 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | No management plan. No plan for BP control, salt/fluid restriction, diet, investigations, dialysis/transplant discussion, no counselling for farmer — work, fluid, salt, follow-up, no reflection, no learning goals | **0 / 2**
### Total Score

*3 / 12 — Developing / Needs Guided Revision*

### CBME Interpretation

*Strengths to keep:*
- Very good characterisation of SOB and swelling separately — onset, aggravating/relieving, site, pitting type — this is good history-taking structure
- Good family history — HTN in both parents is relevant and often missed
- Good negative history — no cough, chest pain, facial puffiness, abdominal distension helps narrow causes

*Gaps that lost 9 points:*
- *Remember (1):* Contradiction loses marks: "Aggravated by lying down" = orthopnea, cannot then say "No orthopnea". In CBME, this suggests history was copied as checklist, not understood.
- *Analyze (0):* SOB + swelling + HTN in a 42M farmer is classic for *both* CKD and heart failure. Portfolio jumps to CKD with no urine history to support it — no oliguria, no frothy urine, no nocturia.
- *Evaluate (0):* BP 160/100 + SpO2 94% + RR 22 + orthopnoea is the most urgent part of this case and is not addressed.

### What would score 12/12 for this same case?

- *Remember (2):* Fix contradiction: "Orthopnea: Present — SOB on lying down, needs 2 pillows" OR "Absent" + add: urine — output, colour, froth, nocturia, haematuria + chest pain, cough, sputum, weight gain, JVP symptoms
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "HTN → damages kidney + heart → fluid retention → swelling + SOB. CKD → fluid overload + anaemia → SOB. Heart failure → fluid in lungs + legs → SOB on lying down + swelling."
- *Apply (2):* Add: JVP, lung crepitations, edema grade, weight, urine output + CBC, urea/creatinine, electrolytes, urine protein, ECG, echo, chest X-ray, USG kidneys
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: CKD vs Heart failure vs Nephrotic vs Liver failure vs Anaemia — SOB pattern, swelling, urine, BP, JVP for each
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "I favour CKD + hypertensive heart disease because HTN 3 years + swelling + SOB, but heart failure must be ruled out first because orthopnea + SpO2 94%. Need ECG + echo + renal function urgently. Safety-net: breathlessness at rest, chest pain, very low urine, swelling worsening → emergency."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — salt/fluid restriction, BP drugs per workup, low salt diet, avoid NSAIDs, regular BP + weight monitoring, farmer work advice — avoid prolonged standing, follow-up with nephrology + cardiology + reflection: "My learning goal: always differentiate cardiac vs renal cause of SOB + swelling, never label CKD without urine + renal tests."

### Evaluator Verdict

*Entrustment:* Not yet entrustable independently. Entrustable with direct supervision for history of SOB + swelling. Needs supervised practice for cardiac vs renal differentiation, investigations, and urgent evaluation.


No comments:

Post a Comment