7/11/2026
Roll no 36's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below
Here is a *12-Point Score* — *Bloom's Taxonomy applied to CBME evaluation* — for this portfolio:* Roll No. 36
*Case:* 32F, Home wife, Dialysis Ward — B/L ankle swelling 3 years + Shortness of breath on walking
*Past History:* K/C/O CKD on maintenance haemodialysis twice weekly for 2 years, HTN + Hypothyroidism for 5 years, on regular medication for both, Diet changed mixed → veg 3 years ago
*Vitals:* PR 98, BP 130/90, Temp 98.4°F, SpO2 98%, *Wt 28 kg*
*Diagnosis given in portfolio:* CKD on maintenance haemodialysis with HTN presenting with B/L ankle oedema & exertional dyspnoea
### Scoring Rule
Each Bloom level = *0 to 2 points*
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not explained
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
Bloom Level | CBME Competency Tested | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. Remember** | Medical knowledge, history taking | Good recall: ankle oedema B/L pitting gradual mild 3 years, SOB on walking/exertion relieved sitting/lying, no fever/burning micturition/oliguria/polyuria, CKD dialysis twice weekly 2 years, HTN + hypothyroid 5 years, diet change, vitals + systemic exam done. BUT critical data missing: dialysis adequacy — last dialysis, urine output, interdialytic weight gain, HTN/thyroid drug names/doses, height/BMI, swelling progression — ankle only or up legs | **1 / 2**
**2. Understand** | Explains disease in own words | Understands CKD → swelling + SOB, but does NOT explain: why swelling 3 years but dialysis only 2 years, why SOB relieved by sitting/lying — not classic orthopnoea, why Wt 28 kg matters — severe malnutrition / low BMI, why hypothyroidism + CKD together worsen swelling/SOB, why diet change to veg matters | **1 / 2**
**3. Apply** | Examination, investigation planning | Good general + systemic exam. BUT no targeted exam: no edema grading, JVP, lung crepitations, weight trend, dialysis access exam, thyroid signs, no investigations listed — no CBC, urea/creatinine, electrolytes, TSH, Hb, albumin, ECG, echo, chest X-ray, dialysis adequacy | **0 / 2**
**4. Analyze** | Differential diagnosis, prioritisation | Only 1 diagnosis restated — CKD on dialysis. No differential for swelling + SOB in young female on dialysis. Missed: Fluid overload / inadequate dialysis vs Heart failure vs Anaemia — Wt 28 kg + CKD vs Hypothyroidism — uncontrolled vs Hypoalbuminaemia / malnutrition vs Pericardial effusion | **0 / 2**
**5. Evaluate** | Decision-making, safety, justification | No evaluation: **Wt 28 kg in a 32F adult = severe undernutrition / possible sarcopenia — must be evaluated, not just copied.** No evaluation of dialysis adequacy — twice weekly for 2 years with persistent swelling = inadequate, no safety-netting for breathlessness at rest, chest pain, very low urine, missed dialysis | **0 / 2**
**6. Create** | Management plan, patient education, reflection | No management plan. No plan for dialysis review, fluid/salt restriction, nutrition, anaemia/thyroid review, physiotherapy, follow-up, no counselling for young housewife on long-term dialysis, no reflection, no learning goals | **0 / 2**
### Total Score
*2 / 12 — Below Expected / Needs Major Revision*
### CBME Interpretation
*Strengths to keep:*
- Best provisional diagnosis in Roll No. 36's batch so far — complete, not just "CKD" — it links CKD + dialysis + HTN + swelling + dyspnoea together
- Good capture of dialysis duration — twice weekly for 2 years — and HTN/thyroid 5 years, showing CKD timeline
- Good negative history — no fever/burning micturition/oliguria/polyuria helps rule out UTI / acute change
*Gaps that lost 10 points:*
- *Apply (0):* Swelling + SOB in a dialysis patient needs JVP, lungs, weight trend, dialysis access, and labs. None done.
- *Evaluate (0):* Most dangerous miss — *Wt 28 kg*. For a 32-year-old adult, this is severe malnutrition. Needs height, BMI, albumin, dietitian review, and cause — CKD anorexia vs poor intake vs thyroid.
- *Analyze (0):* Persistent swelling after 2 years of dialysis = dialysis is not controlling fluid. This must be analysed, not just restated.
### What would score 12/12 for this same case?
- *Remember (2):* Add: Height + BMI, weight trend — 3 years ago vs now, last dialysis date, urine output, interdialytic weight gain, HTN/thyroid drug names/doses, TSH control, swelling — ankle only vs legs/face, orthopnoea/PND
- *Understand (2):* Add 3 lines: "CKD → fluid + waste build up → swelling + SOB. Dialysis twice weekly may be inadequate if swelling persists. Hypothyroidism → swelling + SOB + weight change. Wt 28 kg → malnutrition → low albumin → more swelling."
- *Apply (2):* Add: Edema grade, JVP, lung crepitations, weight, dialysis access + CBC, urea/creatinine, electrolytes, albumin, TSH, ECG, echo, chest X-ray, USG kidneys
- *Analyze (2):* Add table: Fluid overload / inadequate dialysis vs Heart failure vs Hypothyroidism vs Anaemia / malnutrition vs Hypoalbuminaemia — for/against each
- *Evaluate (2):* Add: "I favour inadequate dialysis + malnutrition/hypothyroidism because swelling persists 3 years despite dialysis 2 years + Wt 28 kg. Need dialysis adequacy + TSH + albumin urgently. Safety-net: breathlessness at rest, chest pain, fever, very low urine, missed dialysis → emergency."
- *Create (2):* Add: Complete plan — nephrology + dietitian review, dialysis adequacy, salt/fluid restriction, nutrition rehabilitation, thyroid + anaemia treatment, physiotherapy, follow-up + reflection: "My learning goal: always calculate BMI and check dialysis adequacy when a dialysis patient still has swelling."
### Evaluator Verdict
*Entrustment:* Not entrustable even with direct supervision in current form — needs weight/BMI evaluation, dialysis adequacy review, and targeted examination before filing.
This case shows Roll No. 36 can write a good diagnosis line — now build the examination and nutrition assessment around it.

No comments:
Post a Comment