30/10/2026
Roll no 2's assimilated single patient data linked below
Here is the 6-point CBME evaluation for *2023 Batch - Roll No. 2* - Portfolio: *CASE 1 - 70M, Previously Farmer, SOB - 1 Week,
Swelling Left Face - 1 Week, 5 Days, Swelling Both Feet - 3 Days, Wheezing + Orthopnoea, MMRC IV, Cough - Productive White Sputum, HTN 3 Years - Atenolol 50 mg + Amlodipine 5 mg, Smoking 30 Years - Stopped 10 Years Ago, BP 170/86, SpO2 93%*
Based on the anonymized text you pasted. Score 0-2 per level. Total /12.
### 1. Remember - Knowledge Recall
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Age: 70 years, Sex: M, Occupation: Previously farmer, C/C: SOB - 1 wk, Swelling over left face - 1 wk, 5 days, HOPI: Asymptomatic 2 days ago / 1 wk then developed swelling over left face sudden onset, progressive, No chest pain, palpitation, cough, claudication more in morning, subsides by evening, Then developed SOB aggravated on walking (MMRC grade - IV) progressive, gradual onset, intermittent, associated with wheezing & orthopnea, Then developed swelling over both feet - pitting present - upto ankle 3 days, H/o cough - productive sputum white in color, No fever, cold, burning micturition, allergy, Past H/o: Known case HTN 3 yrs, Medication - Tab Atenolol 50mg + Amlo 5mg, No DM / TB / asthma / epilepsy, Personal H/o: Diet Mixed, Appetite ↓, Sleep disturbed, B & B normal, reg, Addictions - Smoking tobacco for 30 y, stopped 10y ago, Family H/o: Not significant, Gen examination: Pt c/c/c well oriented to TPP O/E, PICCLE (E) (+) 1d B/L pitting edema on both feet (ankle) 4-6mm indentation (Gr III), Systemic: CVS S1 S2 (+) no murmur, CNS NFND, RS Wheeze B/L (+) supramammary inspiratory, P/A distended, Vitals: BP 170/86 mmHg, PR 75/min, Temp Afebrile, SpO2 93% on RA, RR increased.
- Good details: Timeline - face swelling 1 week, SOB 1 week, feet swelling 3 days - chronology clear, SOB pattern - aggravated walking, MMRC IV, progressive, gradual, intermittent, wheezing + orthopnoea, face swelling - sudden, progressive, more morning, subsides evening, feet swelling - pitting, up to ankle, 4-6mm indentation, Gr III, 1d B/L, cough - productive, white sputum, negatives - No fever, cold, burning micturition, allergy, no chest pain, palpitation, drugs - Atenolol 50 mg + Amlodipine 5 mg, smoking - 30 years, stopped 10 years ago, vitals - BP, PR, Temp, SpO2, RR - complete, systemic exam - all 4 systems, PICCLE - E (+) - detailed.
- Gaps: *Contradictions - "asymptomatic 2 days ago / 1 wk"* - which one? *"No H/o cough"* vs *"H/o cough - productive sputum white"* - contradiction. *No Provisional Diagnosis - COPD? Heart failure? CKD? - not written.* *No Investigations - Chest X-ray, ECG, CBC, RFT.* *No SpO2 trend, No RR number* - "increased" - not a number. *P/A distended* - not explained - ascites? Gas? *RS "supramammary inspiratory"* - unclear. *Face swelling - left face only* - not examined - unilateral vs bilateral? *No JVP, No Lung crepitations.*
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial recall - SOB + edema + wheeze + vitals good, but contradictions, diagnosis, investigations missing.
- *Next target:* Clean contradictions before submitting - Asymptomatic 1 week ago or 2 days ago? Cough present or absent? Always record Provisional Diagnosis. Always record Investigations - Chest X-ray, ECG, CBC, RFT, ABG, Spirometry. Always record RR as a number - e.g. 24/min - not "increased". Always record P/A - distended - due to what? Ascites? Hepatomegaly? Gas? Always record Face swelling - inspection: unilateral left, eye, lip, tender?, JVP, RS - crepitations?, Wheeze - inspiratory / expiratory?
### 2. Understand - Comprehension
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- SOB MMRC IV + wheezing + orthopnoea + pedal edema Gr III + face swelling more morning, subsides evening + productive white sputum - described.
- But no explanation in own words of why SOB + wheeze + edema occur together, why face swelling more morning, why smoking 30 years matters.
- No explanation of MMRC IV - what it means - not explained.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial comprehension.
- *Next target:* Explain: MMRC IV = SOB on minimal activity, cannot leave house, stops after 100m / few minutes, too breathless to dress. Explain: SOB aggravated walking + wheezing + orthopnoea + pedal edema = heart failure / COPD - fluid overload + airway obstruction. Explain: Face swelling more morning, subsides evening = fluid retention overnight, renal / cardiac, or allergy / angioedema. Explain: Smoking 30 years, stopped 10 years ago = COPD risk, airway damage persists. Explain: Productive white sputum = COPD / bronchitis, not infection - Afebrile, no fever. Explain: BP 170/86 = uncontrolled HTN, SpO2 93% = low, RR increased = tachypnoea due to SOB. Explain: Atenolol - beta-blocker - can worsen wheezing / COPD - important.
### 3. Apply - Application to Patient Care
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Drugs - Atenolol 50 mg + Amlodipine 5 mg - mentioned.
- Systemic examination done.
- But no student plan - no investigation plan, no management plan.
- No application of MMRC IV + SpO2 93% + BP 170/86 to care - no urgent oxygen, no BP control.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial application - vitals + systemic exam applied, but no care plan.
- *Next target:* Add: Chest X-ray, ECG, CBC - Hb, RFT - urea, creatinine, ABG, Spirometry, 2D Echo. Add management - Oxygen if SpO2 low, Nebulisation if wheeze, avoid Atenolol - beta-blocker worsens wheeze - discuss with Medicine - switch antihypertensive, Continue Amlodipine, check BP, Fluid restriction, low salt, daily weight, Diuretics - Furosemide if fluid overload, Bronchodilators if COPD, Stop smoking - already stopped, Follow-up, Refer - Medicine / Pulmonology / Cardiology. Add: If MMRC IV + orthopnoea + SpO2 93% - urgent - check lungs, ECG, Chest X-ray, admit.
### 4. Analyze - Differentiation & Interpretation
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- No provisional diagnosis, no differential list.
- No analysis of alternative causes: COPD vs Heart failure vs CKD vs Asthma vs Pneumonia.
- No analysis of face swelling - unilateral left face - allergy / angioedema / cellulitis / renal / cardiac - not differentiated.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial analysis - SOB + wheeze + edema pattern recognized, but not differentiated.
- *Next target:* Add differential table: COPD Exacerbation - supports 70M, smoking 30 years, SOB MMRC IV, wheezing B/L, productive white sputum, orthopnoea, sleep disturbed, appetite ↓; against - pedal edema Gr III, face swelling, P/A distended not explained by COPD alone, no fever. Heart Failure - supports 70M, HTN 3 years, SOB MMRC IV, orthopnoea, pedal edema Gr III pitting, face swelling more morning, P/A distended - ascites, BP 170/86, SpO2 93%; against - wheezing B/L - could be cardiac asthma, no chest pain, palpitation, S1 S2 normal, no murmur. CKD - supports edema feet + face, HTN, SOB; against - no oliguria, dysuria, B&B normal, no RFT given. Asthma - supports wheezing; against - 70M, smoking, productive sputum, no allergy, no episodic history. Pneumonia - supports SOB, cough; against - Afebrile, sputum white, no fever, cold. Must analyze: Is wheeze due to COPD or cardiac asthma? Is face swelling due to renal, cardiac, allergy, or angioedema - Amlodipine can cause pedal edema, not face swelling.
### 5. Evaluate - Judgment & Reflection
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- Negatives - No fever, cold, burning micturition, allergy, no chest pain, palpitation - show judgment.
- PICCLE - E (+) Gr III, 4-6mm indentation - shows judgment - you graded edema.
- MMRC IV - shows judgment - you graded SOB.
- But no judgment on contradictions - cough present vs absent, asymptomatic 2 days vs 1 week - not evaluated.
- No judgment on BP 170/86, SpO2 93%, Atenolol + wheeze - not flagged.
- No reflection.
*Score: 1 / 2*
- Partial evaluation - edema grading + MMRC + negatives show judgment, but contradictions / drug interaction missed.
- *Next target:* Add: Can I label COPD / Heart failure without Chest X-ray / ECG / Echo? What is most urgent - MMRC IV + orthopnoea + SpO2 93% + BP 170/86 + edema Gr III - is he in respiratory / heart failure? What is the risk if I miss heart failure / COPD exacerbation / pulmonary edema? What is the risk of Atenolol - beta-blocker - in a 70M with wheezing B/L? Should Atenolol be stopped / changed? What would I do differently - clarify cough, clarify timeline, check JVP, crepitations, face swelling - eye, lip, tender?, ask about Amlodipine edema, allergy? Reflection on 70M previously farmer, smoking 30 years, HTN - impact on work, family, breathing, walking, sleep.
### 6. Create - Synthesis & New Learning Product
*Evidence in portfolio:*
- No original product - no algorithm, concept map, patient education material.
*Score: 0 / 2*
- Not met.
- *Next target:* Create 1-page algorithm: SOB MMRC IV + Wheeze + Orthopnoea + Pedal Edema + Face Swelling -> COPD vs Heart Failure vs CKD -> Examination -> Chest X-ray + ECG + Echo + RFT -> Management, OR patient education sheet for SOB + Edema - salt / fluid, daily weight, BP monitoring, stop smoking, when to go to hospital - severe SOB, chest pain, swelling.
### Summary Sheet - Roll No. 2 - 2023 Batch
Bloom Level | Score /2 | Key Feedback
1. Remember | 1 | SOB + edema grading + vitals good, contradictions, diagnosis missing
2. Understand | 1 | SOB + wheeze + edema described, COPD / heart failure mechanism not explained
3. Apply | 1 | Vitals + exam applied, no Chest X-ray / oxygen / drug plan
4. Analyze | 1 | SOB + wheeze + edema recognized, no differential table
5. Evaluate | 1 | Edema + MMRC grading show judgment, Atenolol + wheeze missed
6. Create | 0 | No original product
**Total** | **5 / 12** | **Developing - Competent**
*Overall CBME Feedback for Roll 2 - Progression:*
- *This portfolio = 5 / 12* - First case for Roll 2
- *Strength:* Edema grading is your best work - PICCLE E (+) 1d B/L pitting edema, 4-6mm indentation, Gr III, up to ankle - that is exactly how edema should be graded, and no one else in this batch did it this well. MMRC IV + wheezing + orthopnoea + productive white sputum + smoking 30 years is also a good COPD / heart failure story. Vitals - BP 170/86, PR 75, Temp Afebrile, SpO2 93% on RA - are complete.
- *Critical learning from this case:* Two traps - 1) Contradictions - "No cough" vs "Cough productive white", "Asymptomatic 2 days ago" vs "1 week" - fix them. 2) Atenolol + wheeze - Atenolol is a beta-blocker, it can worsen wheezing / COPD - in a 70M with wheeze B/L, you must flag it. And BP 170/86 + SpO2 93% + MMRC IV + orthopnoea are red flags - you must flag urgency. Add Provisional Diagnosis + Chest X-ray + ECG + Echo + RR number + JVP + Face swelling exam, and this case becomes 8-9/12.
For patient centered CBME online learning portfolio assessment methodology details and further reading please click here:

No comments:
Post a Comment