Friday, November 13, 2026

2023 Roll no 23 CBME competence based assessment of a single patient portfolio 60M knee pains 1 yr blurring vision 2 yrs

 
5/11/2026

Roll no 23's assimilated single patient data linked below

*Six Point Method - CBME Portfolio Evaluation*
*Portfolio To Evaluate:* Individual anonymized online learning portfolio, 2023 batch, Roll Number 23

*Case-2 In Portfolio:* 60-year-old male, labourer, both knees pain since 7 years, bilateral blurring of vision since 2 years, difficulty walking, known DM and HTN, previous knee injury, smoking and alcohol present, provisional diagnosis bilateral knee osteoarthritis

*How To Use This Method*

- *Reviewer:* Faculty evaluator, blinded to student name
- *Source:* Only the anonymized blog entries, reflections, images, and linked work for Roll 23
- *Score:* 0 to 5 for each Bloom level, total 30
- *Evidence:* Score only what is actually present in the portfolio, not what is assumed
Point | Bloom Level | What To Look For In The Portfolio | Portfolio Evidence For This Case | Score 0 To 5
1 | Remember | Accurate recall of facts, definitions, and lists | Defines OA, lists risk factors like age, male sex, labour work, previous injury, obesity, DM, lists causes of bilateral blurring of vision like cataract, diabetic retinopathy, refractive error | 0 = Missing, 1 = Incomplete, 2 = Basic List, 3 = Accurate List, 4 = Accurate And Organized, 5 = Accurate, Organized, And Referenced
2 | Understand | Explains meaning, compares, and interprets | Explains why 7 years insidious progressive knee pain favors OA, explains why vision loss for 2 years may be separate and linked to DM and age, explains link of DM, HTN, and OA through metabolic factors | 0 = No Explanation, 1 = Copies Text, 2 = Partial Explanation, 3 = Clear Explanation, 4 = Explains With Case Link, 5 = Explains With Case Link And Diagram Or Analogy
3 | Apply | Uses knowledge in this real case | Takes structured history of knee pain and vision loss separately, documents onset gradual, duration, progression, difficulty walking, DM and HTN history, smoking and alcohol, examines swelling, deformity, movements, GCS 15/15, RS, CNS, abdomen, vitals | 0 = No Application, 1 = Generic History, 2 = Case History Present, 3 = Structured History And Exam, 4 = Structured And Complete, 5 = Structured, Complete, And Patient Centred
4 | Analyze | Breaks down case, differentiates, finds patterns | Differentiates OA knee from rheumatoid arthritis, gout, and post traumatic arthritis, differentiates cataract from diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma, analyzes whether knee and vision problems share DM as common cause or are unrelated | 0 = No Analysis, 1 = Single Diagnosis Only, 2 = Lists Differentials, 3 = Differentials With Reasons, 4 = Differentials With For And Against, 5 = Prioritized Differentials With Case Evidence
5 | Evaluate | Judges investigations, management, and safety | Justifies X-ray both knees, blood sugar, HbA1c, BP, lipids, eye examination and referral to ophthalmology, evaluates safe analgesia in DM and HTN, evaluates smoking and alcohol cessation, evaluates fall risk | 0 = No Plan, 1 = Plan Without Justification, 2 = Plan With Basic Justification, 3 = Appropriate Plan, 4 = Appropriate And Safe Plan, 5 = Appropriate, Safe, And Evidence Based Plan
6 | Create | Produces new, original, reflective work | Creates patient specific plan for knee care, physiotherapy, weight control, DM and HTN control, eye care follow up, smoking and alcohol counseling, reflection on learning from two system case, patient education in simple language | 0 = No Original Work, 1 = Copies Plan, 2 = Basic Plan, 3 = Patient Specific Plan, 4 = Patient Specific Plan Plus Reflection, 5 = Original Plan Plus Reflection Plus Improvement For Next Case
*CBME Competency Mapping For Roll 23*

- *Knowledge:* Points 1 and 2
- *Clinical Skills:* Point 3
- *Clinical Reasoning:* Point 4
- *Decision Making:* Point 5
- *Professionalism And Communication:* Point 6
- *Attitude, Ethics, And Communication Module:* Check for deidentification, respectful language, empathy, and consent in blog

*Scoring And Feedback Guide*

- *Total Score:* Add 6 levels, maximum 30
- *24 To 30:* Competent, portfolio shows independent learning, ready for next level
- *18 To 23:* Developing competence, needs targeted feedback on lowest 2 levels
- *12 To 17:* Below expected, needs remediation and resubmission of weak levels
- *Below 12:* Not competent, needs supervised rework and faculty mentoring
- *Mandatory Checks:* Portfolio must be anonymized, no patient name, address, phone, or hospital number, no copied text without reference, reflection must be in student's own words, unclear entries must be marked as unclear and not guessed

*Evaluator Checklist For This Specific Case*

- *Remember Check:* Did Roll 23 list causes of bilateral blurring of vision in DM?
- *Understand Check:* Did Roll 23 explain the different timelines, 7 years knee pain vs 2 years vision loss?
- *Apply Check:* Did Roll 23 document knee examination, vision history, DM and HTN history, and addictions?
- *Analyze Check:* Did Roll 23 decide if knee and vision problems are linked by DM or separate?
- *Evaluate Check:* Did Roll 23 justify eye referral and safe drug choices in DM and HTN?
- *Create Check:* Did Roll 23 create a usable plan for knee, vision, DM, HTN, smoking, and alcohol?

*Final Evaluator Note Format*

- *Roll Number:* 23, 2023 Batch
- *Portfolio Link:* Anonymized blog only
- *Case-2:* 60M, Both Knees Pain 7 Years, Bilateral Blurring Vision 2 Years
- *Scores By Level:* Remember * / 5, Understand * / 5, Apply * / 5, Analyze * / 5, Evaluate * / 5, Create * / 5
- *Total:* __ / 30
- *Strengths:* 
- *Areas To Improve:* 
- *Feedback For Student:* 
- *Decision:* Competent / Developing / Needs Remediation

For patient centered CBME online learning portfolio assessment methodology details and further reading please click here: 

No comments:

Post a Comment