Monday, November 16, 2026

48F Giddiness pain in lower abdomen burning micturition

 
13/11/2026

THIS PATIENT DATA WAS GATHERED BY ROLL NO 21 BATCH 2023 AS PART OF HER COMPETENCE BASED LEARNING EVALUATION PORTFOLIO PREPARATION

*Date:* 13/11/26
*Roll No:* 21
*Batch:* 2023

*Patient Details:*
- Age: 48 years
- Gender: Female
- Occupation: Housewife

*Chief Complaints (C/o):*
- Patient came to OPD with:
- Giddiness - 1 month
- Pain in lower abdomen - 1 month
- Burning micturition - 1 month

*History of Present Illness (HOPI):*
- Patient was apparently asymptomatic 1 month back, then developed pain in right lower abdomen radiating to front, insidious in onset, aggravated during work or weight lifting, relieved during rest
- Patient has pain in lateral / medial sleeping posture, is only sleeping in supine position
- Giddiness is aggravated / seen during work, associated with burning micturition since 1 month

*Past History:*
- History of renal stones 11 years back
- N/K/C HTN - 10 years
- DM - 10 years
- N/K/C Asthma / Epilepsy / TB / COPD / Thyroid
- Family history: Not significant

*Medication History:*
- History of medications of HTN & DM

*Surgical History:*
- Previous renal stone surgery done 11 years back

*Personal History:*
- Diet: Mixed
- Sleep: Normal
- Appetite: Decreased
- Addictions: Alcohol - 30 yrs
- BSB: Burning micturition

*General Examination:*
- Patient is well oriented to time, place & person
- P I C C L E - Negative
- Hb: Low

*Vitals:*
- Temp - Afebrile
- BP - 120/80 mmHg (on medication)
- PR - 68/min
- HR - 68/min
- RS - 17 cpm
- SpO2 - 98% @ RA

*Systemic Examination:*
- CVS - S1, S2 (+)
- CNS - NVNF
- RS - B/L, NVBS
- PA - Soft, NT

*Provisional Diagnosis:*
- Most likely Recurrent Renal stones
Scar of previous renal stones removal surgery


*Socratic Questions - For Medical Student Learning*
*Case:* 13/11/26, Roll No. 21, Batch 2023
48F, Giddiness, Lower abdominal pain, Burning micturition x 1 month, HTN + DM x 10 years, Renal stones 11 years back, Alcohol history, Appetite decreased, Hb low, BP 120/80 on medication, Provisional Diagnosis: Recurrent Renal Stones

Use these questions to think, not to memorise answers. Try to answer each one before moving to the next.

### 1. History - What Are We Really Asking?

- Why is it important to ask about _onset, radiation, aggravating and relieving factors_ for this pain, rather than just "where does it hurt?"
- The pain is worse on working / weight lifting and better on rest, and worse in lateral sleeping posture. What does that tell you? What does it _not_ tell you?
- Why would you ask about fever, hematuria, frequency, urgency, vaginal discharge, and menstrual history in a 48-year-old female with dysuria? What would each answer change?
- Giddiness for 1 month in a patient with HTN + DM - what 4 different systems could this come from? How would you separate them by history alone?
- Why does a history of renal stone surgery 11 years ago matter _now_? Does a past stone make a future stone more likely, or less likely? Why?
- Appetite is decreased and Hb is low. Is that a coincidence, or could it be connected to this illness? How would you explore it?

### 2. Personal History - What Does It Add?

- Diet is mixed, sleep is normal, appetite is decreased. Which of these is most concerning here, and why?
- Alcohol history is documented. How might alcohol affect BP, blood sugar, appetite, and renal health in this patient? Should you ask more - how much, how often, withdrawal symptoms?
- Why is it important to document BSB - Bowel, Bladder, Sleep, Appetite - even when the main complaint is pain?

### 3. Examination - What Are You Looking For?

- The patient is well oriented to time, place and person. Why document this in a patient presenting with giddiness?
- What does P I C C L E stand for? Why is it negative here important, especially with low Hb?
- Vitals are BP 120/80 on medication, PR 68, SpO2 98% RA, afebrile. Does a normal BP _now_ mean HTN is well-controlled? What else would you want to know?
- If Hb is low, what would you expect to find on general examination? What would you look for that is _not_ written here?
- PA is soft, NT - non-tender. Does that rule out renal stones? Why or why not? What examination finding would make you _more_ worried about stones - renal angle tenderness, guarding, or something else?
- CVS S1 S2 (+), CNS NVNF, RS B/L NVBS - what are you actually ruling out with each of these in this case?

### 4. Analysis - Differential Diagnosis

- Why is "Recurrent Renal Stones" chosen as most likely? What history findings support it, and what findings go _against_ it?
- What are your top 3 differentials other than stones? For each one, what is one finding for it and one finding against it?
- Could this be _both_ a UTI _and_ stones at the same time? How do stones and infection make each other worse?
- How would you differentiate lower UTI, pyelonephritis, and renal colic at the bedside, before any test?

### 5. Understanding - Connecting DM, HTN, and Kidney

- Why does a patient with DM for 10 years get more UTIs than a patient without DM? Think about sugar, immunity, and bladder function.
- Why does HTN for 10 years matter for the kidney? Is HTN a cause of kidney damage, a result of it, or both?
- If this patient has diabetic kidney disease developing, would you expect pain? Why is pain actually _not_ typical for diabetic nephropathy?
- How could recurrent stones lead to chronic kidney damage over time?

### 6. Evaluation - Investigations

- If you could order only 3 investigations first, which 3 would you choose and why? What question would each one answer?
- What would a urine routine show if this is UTI? What would it show if this is stones? What if both are present?
- Why is urine culture more important than just urine routine here?
- What would you look for on USG abdomen / KUB? What would a normal USG mean - does it rule out stones?
- Hb is low. Which test would you do next to understand _why_ it is low? Is it related to chronic disease, blood loss, nutrition, or all three?
- When would you check HbA1c, RFT, calcium, and uric acid? What would each one change in your management?

### 7. Create - Management and Prevention

- What would you do _today_ for pain, dysuria, and giddiness? What would you _avoid_ doing, and why?
- How would you counsel this patient about fluid intake, diet, alcohol, and medication adherence? What would you prioritise first?
- If the urine culture is positive, how would you choose an antibiotic in a diabetic patient with possible renal impairment? Why does renal function matter for drug choice?
- When would you refer to Urology / Nephrology / Medicine? What would be your referral question?
- How would you follow up this patient in 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months? What would you check at each visit to know she is getting better - or worse?
- What is the one lifestyle change that would reduce _both_ stone recurrence _and_ UTI recurrence _and_ improve HTN and DM? Why is it so hard for patients to follow it?

### 8. Reflection - Professionalism

- What did you miss in this history or examination that you would not miss next time?
- How did you ensure the patient's privacy while documenting this case? Why does deidentification matter for learning portfolios?
- If this patient was worried and asked, "Will I need surgery again?", how would you answer honestly without alarming her?

*How to Use These in Teaching:*
1. Pick 1 question from each section for bedside discussion
2. Let the student answer, then ask "Why do you think that?" and "What else could it be?"
3. End by asking the student to write their own 3 questions for the next case

No comments:

Post a Comment