Roll no 21's assimilated single patient portfolio linked below
Here is the *same Six-Point CBME Assessment, now scored out of 12 points* for this portfolio:* Roll No. 21, 2023 Batch
*Case:* 45M, Unemployed — Fatigue + Difficulty in Breathing 2 yrs + Knee Pains + Difficulty in Walking 1 month
*Diagnosis given:* CKD
### Scoring Rule — 6 Domains x 2 Points = 12 Points
- *0 =* Absent / incorrect / unsafe
- *1 =* Partial / listed but not justified
- *2 =* Complete, justified, patient-centred
- *Total = /12*
No. | CBME Domain | Evidence in This Portfolio | Score
**1. History Taking** | Complete HOPI + negatives + personal history | Good: SOB Grade 2 → Grade 4 over 2 yrs, worse on work, better on rest, knee pain ankle → knee, no weight gain / fever / vomiting, HTN 2 yrs on Amlodipine 10 mg, appetite reduced, sleep disturbed, bowel & bladder reduced. Missing: Urine — volume, froth, blood, dysuria, nocturia, SOB — cough, wheeze, PND, orthopnoea, chest pain, knee — swelling, stiffness, trauma | **1 / 2**
**2. Physical Examination** | General + vitals + systemic + focused exam | Good: Conscious, coherent, cooperative, PICCLE — Pallor (+ve), vitals complete, CNS/CVS/RS/P/A done. Missing: JVP, lung bases / crepitations, oedema grade, weight, knee / ankle joint exam — swelling, tenderness, ROM, kidney palpation | **1 / 2**
**3. Clinical Reasoning** | Differential + prioritisation + justification | Only 1 diagnosis — CKD — no differential. No reasoning for CKD vs Heart Failure vs Anaemia vs CKD-MBD / Arthritis vs COPD / Asthma. No link of Pallor + Fatigue → anaemia in CKD, or Amlodipine → ankle swelling | **0 / 2**
**4. Investigation Planning** | Appropriate, justified investigations | No investigations listed. No CBC, creatinine/eGFR, urine routine, electrolytes, calcium / phosphate / PTH, USG KUB, ECG, chest X-ray, X-ray knee — diagnosis cannot be confirmed or staged | **0 / 2**
**5. Management & Safety** | Management plan, counselling, red-flag safety-net | No management plan. No salt/fluid advice, BP control, anaemia correction, avoid NSAIDs, physiotherapy, dialysis counselling, follow-up. No safety-net: worsening SOB, chest pain, decreased urine, altered sensorium → emergency | **0 / 2**
**6. Professionalism & Documentation** | Complete, legible, patient-centred, reflective | Good structure, date + roll no, de-identified, clear headings. Missing: Patient education, reflection, learning goals, consent / confidentiality note | **1 / 2**
### Total Score
*3 / 12 — Below Expected / Needs Major Revision*
*Conversion:* 3 / 12 = 1.5 / 6 = 25%
### CBME Interpretation
*Strengths to keep:*
- Very good progression — SOB Grade 2 → Grade 4 over 2 years
- Very good link — Fatigue + Pallor (+ve) + SOB — strongest clue for anaemia in CKD
- Very good negatives — No weight gain, fever, vomiting + N/K/C/O DM, Asthma, TB, COPD, Epilepsy
*Gaps that lost 9 points:*
- *Clinical Reasoning (0/2):* No differential — heart failure and anaemia can present exactly like this
- *Investigations (0/2):* No investigations — CKD cannot be diagnosed on history + pallor alone
- *Management (0/2):* No plan, no counselling, no safety-net — unsafe to file
### What would score 12/12 for this same case?
- *1. History (2/2):* Add urine, SOB — NYHA / mMRC, cough, PND, orthopnoea, chest pain, knee — swelling, stiffness, trauma, swelling — grade, weight gain
- *2. Examination (2/2):* Add JVP, lung bases, oedema grade, weight, knee / ankle — swelling, tenderness, ROM, kidney palpation, pallor grading + interpretation of PR 98, BP 110/90
- *3. Reasoning (2/2):* Add table: CKD vs Heart Failure vs Anaemia vs CKD-MBD / Arthritis vs COPD / Asthma — for / against, with conclusion favouring CKD but ruling out others
- *4. Investigations (2/2):* Add CBC, creatinine/eGFR, urine routine, electrolytes, calcium / phosphate / PTH, USG KUB, ECG, chest X-ray, X-ray knee — with expected findings
- *5. Management (2/2):* Add salt/fluid restriction, BP control, anaemia correction, avoid NSAIDs, physiotherapy, follow-up, dialysis counselling, safety-net
- *6. Professionalism (2/2):* Add counselling + reflection: "My learning goal: never diagnose CKD without urine + creatinine + USG, and always examine JVP + lung bases + joints in SOB + knee pain."
### Evaluator Verdict
*Entrustment:* Not entrustable even with direct supervision in current form — needs focused joint + chest exam, differential, and investigations before filing.

No comments:
Post a Comment